The Shocking Truth: The Etsy Exodus Explained

The Shocking Truth: The Etsy Exodus Explained

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Why People Quit Etsy
    • Lack of Control
    • High Competition and Lower Prices
    • Rising Fees and Hidden Costs
    • Difficulty in Promoting and Branding
  3. The Importance of Having a Brand
  4. Building Your Own Online Store
  5. Driving Traffic to Your Store
  6. Creating Relationships with Customers
  7. Upselling and Becoming a Top Brand
  8. Balancing Financials and Managing Costs
  9. Considering Alternatives to Etsy
  10. Conclusion

Why Everyone is Quitting Etsy and You Should Too

In recent years, there has been a growing trend of artists and small business owners quitting Etsy, the popular online marketplace. This video, with over 10,000 views, explores the reasons behind this mass exodus and why you should consider following suit. While Etsy may seem like a perfect platform for creative entrepreneurs to showcase and sell their products, it has its drawbacks that are causing more and more people to look for alternatives.

Lack of Control

One of the main reasons artists and designers are leaving Etsy is the lack of control they have over their own businesses. By selling on Etsy, you essentially become an employee of the platform, working to provide them with new products and drive traffic to their site. This shift in perspective has led many sellers to realize that they want to have their own machine working for them, rather than working for a platform that demands constant attention and new products.

High Competition and Lower Prices

Another issue with Etsy is the increasing competition and the pressure to lower prices. As more sellers join the platform, the market becomes saturated, making it harder for individual sellers to stand out. In order to stay competitive, sellers often have to reduce their prices, resulting in lower profits and a constant need to create and offer more products. This can be exhausting and take away from the joy of creating.

Rising Fees and Hidden Costs

Etsy's fees and hidden costs are also contributing factors to sellers leaving the platform. Sellers are required to pay listing fees, transaction fees, off-site ads fees, and more. These fees can quickly add up and eat into profits, especially for sellers who may already be struggling to make a decent income. Additionally, Etsy's fee structure is often complex and confusing, making it difficult for sellers to accurately calculate their expenses and profits.

Difficulty in Promoting and Branding

Promoting and branding on Etsy can be challenging due to the limited visibility for individual sellers. With countless sellers and listings on the platform, it can be difficult for sellers to gain exposure and attract customers. To succeed on Etsy, sellers have to rely on Etsy's algorithms to match their products with interested buyers, which can be unpredictable and unreliable. Building a unique brand and establishing a strong online presence requires more control and flexibility than what Etsy can offer.

The Importance of Having a Brand

In today's competitive online marketplace, having a strong brand is essential for success. Building a brand allows you to differentiate yourself from the competition, attract loyal customers, and command higher prices. By creating a unique brand identity and focusing on quality products, you can establish yourself as a trusted and reputable seller.

Building Your Own Online Store

Instead of relying solely on platforms like Etsy, many sellers are opting to build their own online stores. By having your own e-commerce website, you gain full control over your business and can create a customized shopping experience for your customers. This also eliminates the need to pay listing fees and other platform charges, allowing you to keep more of your profits.

Driving Traffic to Your Store

Once you have your own online store, the challenge becomes driving traffic to it. Social media and strategic advertising can play a crucial role in attracting visitors to your store. By creating engaging content, using relevant keywords and hashtags, and targeting the right audience, you can increase visibility and generate more sales.

Creating Relationships with Customers

Building relationships with your customers is an important aspect of running your own online store. By providing exceptional customer service and personalized experiences, you can foster loyalty and turn one-time buyers into repeat customers. This level of interaction is often difficult to achieve on marketplaces like Etsy, where the focus is on the transaction rather than the relationship.

Upselling and Becoming a Top Brand

With your own online store, you have the opportunity to upsell and offer additional products to your customers. By understanding their preferences and interests, you can recommend complementary items and increase your average order value. This strategy not only boosts your sales but also positions you as a top brand in your niche.

Balancing Financials and Managing Costs

Managing your financials is crucial for the success of your online store. By accurately tracking your expenses, including production costs, fees, and advertising expenses, you can ensure that you are pricing your products profitably. Understanding your profit margins and managing your cash flow will allow you to make informed decisions and grow your business effectively.

Considering Alternatives to Etsy

While leaving Etsy may seem like a daunting decision, it is important to explore alternative platforms and strategies that can better support your business goals. Research and evaluate different options, such as other online marketplaces, social media platforms, or even starting your own shop website. Each option has its pros and cons, so consider your unique needs and aspirations before making a decision.


Quitting Etsy and exploring alternative avenues for selling your products is a decision that requires careful consideration. While Etsy may have its benefits, such as an established customer base and an easy-to-use platform, it also comes with limitations and challenges that can hinder your business growth. By taking control of your brand, driving traffic to your own online store, and building strong customer relationships, you can create a more sustainable and profitable business in the long run.

Are you spending too much time looking for products?
App rating
Trending Product
Trusted Customers

Etsyshop has the world's largest selection of ETSY store to choose from, and each product has a large number of ETSY products, so you can choose ETSY store & product for your Ecommerce and dropshipping business without any hassle.

Browse More Content