Maximizing Profit: Etsy vs Poshmark

Maximizing Profit: Etsy vs Poshmark

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction
  2. Understanding the Fees Associated with Running a Small Business
    • 2.1 The Importance of Fees in Small Business
    • 2.2 Exploring Different Platforms: Etsy and Poshmark
  3. Breaking Down Etsy Fees
    • 3.1 Static Fees on Etsy
    • 3.2 Additional Fees on Etsy
  4. Comparing Etsy and Poshmark Fees
    • 4.1 Etsy Fees vs. Poshmark Fees for a $9.95 Item
    • 4.2 Etsy Fees vs. Poshmark Fees for a $50 Item
  5. Is It Worth Selling on Etsy?
    • 5.1 Assessing Profitability for Different Items
    • 5.2 Factors to Consider: Time, Labor, and Return on Investment
  6. The Benefits and Limitations of Poshmark
    • 6.1 Target Audience and Platform Differentiation
    • 6.2 Analyzing Profitability on Poshmark
  7. Conclusion
  8. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)


Understanding the Fees Associated with Running a Small Business

As a small business owner, it is essential to familiarize yourself with the fees that come along with managing your operations. While fees may not be the most exciting topic, they have a significant impact on your profitability. In this article, we will explore the various fees that entrepreneurs often encounter and compare two popular e-commerce platforms, Etsy and Poshmark, to determine which one may be a better fit for your business.

Breaking Down Etsy Fees

Etsy, one of the most well-known platforms for handmade and unique products, has a range of fees that sellers should be aware of. Let's first examine the static fees on Etsy, which are set and do not change based on the transaction type. One such fee is the 20 cents listing fee, which applies to each item listed, whether it's a physical or digital product. This fee cannot be avoided and serves as a basic cost of doing business on Etsy.

Moving on to additional fees on Etsy, we encounter the shipping transaction fee. If you choose to purchase shipping labels through Etsy, a 5% fee is added to the total cost of the shipping label. While this fee may seem insignificant, it can accumulate if you frequently spend a substantial amount on shipping.

Another significant fee is the transaction fee, which amounts to 5% of the total item cost plus shipping and gift wrap fees in your listed currency. This fee applies to every transaction made on Etsy. If you use Square for transactions or participate in pop-up events, additional Square fees will also come into play.

Furthermore, there are processing fees associated with Etsy Payments, their integrated payment system. With Etsy Payments, sellers are charged 3% of the total amount a customer paid, including shipping and taxes, plus an additional 25 cents per transaction. These fees are crucial to note as they directly impact your earnings.

Additionally, there are fees related to advertising on Etsy. Off-site ads refer to fees charged if your items sell through advertisements positioned outside the Etsy platform. Etsy charges an extra 15% fee on the sale price for such transactions. While this may initially seem burdensome, keep in mind that only selected items are promoted off-site by Etsy. The second advertising option, Etsy ads, is voluntary and allows sellers to promote their listings within the platform.

By now, it's evident that Etsy fees can be complex and have an impact on your profitability. Let's delve further into the fees and make a clear comparison with Poshmark.

Comparing Etsy and Poshmark Fees

To determine the best platform for your business, it's crucial to compare the fees associated with both Etsy and Poshmark, taking into account different price points. Let's examine the fees for a $9.95 item first.

On Etsy, selling a $9.95 item incurs a 20 cents listing fee and a 5% transaction fee, resulting in $6.23. Additionally, there is a 5% shipping transaction fee and potential advertising fees if your items sell through off-site ads. Taking these fees into account, the total profit comes to $3.85.

In contrast, Poshmark charges a $2.95 fee for a $9.95 item, which leaves the seller with $6.95 in profit. Poshmark does not have listing or shipping fees, simplifying the fee structure for sellers.

Moving on to a higher-priced item, let's consider a $50 item. On Etsy, the fees for this item include a 20 cents listing fee, a 5% transaction fee, a shipping fee, potential advertising fees, and processing fees if customers pay through Etsy Payments. After factoring in these fees, the total profit amounts to $10.

Comparatively, Poshmark charges a 20% fee, resulting in a fee of $10.40. However, with Poshmark, there are no additional fees or shipping costs, meaning the seller will make $39.60 in profit.

Is It Worth Selling on Etsy?

After analyzing the fees associated with selling on Etsy, you may be wondering if it's worthwhile to sell your products on this platform. The answer depends on various factors, such as the profitability of your items, the time investment required, and the return on investment.

For lower-priced items like the $9.95 coaster, the profit margin on Etsy may be narrower compared to Poshmark. Considering the effort and time spent on creating and listing the item, you need to evaluate if the return justifies the investment. However, digital items, such as stickers or downloadable products, offer an opportunity for higher profit margins without incurring additional shipping or production costs.

On the other hand, high-value items, like upcycled clothing priced at $50 or more, tend to generate more favorable profit margins on Etsy. Cross-listing on Poshmark may also be an option to explore because it attracts a different target audience, but keep in mind the limitations of the platform, such as its search functionality.

Ultimately, the decision to sell on Etsy depends on your product offering, target audience, and desired profit margins. It is vital to take into account all the fees associated with each platform and analyze how they align with your business goals.

The Benefits and Limitations of Poshmark

While Etsy caters to a specific audience interested in handmade and unique items, Poshmark has a different target market primarily focused on fashion, sneakers, and accessories. As a newer platform, Poshmark is still expanding its offerings and user base. However, it does present some advantages and limitations worth considering.

Poshmark charges a flat 20% fee on each item sold, regardless of the selling price. This straightforward fee structure simplifies pricing for sellers. Additionally, Poshmark does not impose listing or shipping fees, making it easier to calculate your potential profits.

However, Poshmark's search functionality is often criticized for being difficult to navigate and overwhelming for users. This limitation may hinder the visibility and discoverability of your products. It's crucial to consider these factors when deciding whether to list your items on Poshmark alongside Etsy or solely on Etsy.


Understanding the fees associated with running a small business is essential for maximizing profitability. In this article, we explored the fees on Etsy and compared them to those on Poshmark to help you make informed decisions about selling platforms. It is crucial to assess the profitability of your products, the target audience of each platform, and the efforts required to maintain and promote your listings.

Remember, the choice between Etsy and Poshmark depends on your specific business needs, product offerings, and desired profit margins. By carefully considering these factors and the fees involved, you can make informed decisions that align with your goals and ultimately lead to a successful e-commerce venture.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: Are there any fees associated with listing items on Etsy? A: Yes, there is a static listing fee of 20 cents for each item listed on Etsy, whether it is a physical or digital product.

Q: Does Poshmark charge additional fees for shipping? A: No, Poshmark does not charge separate fees for shipping. The selling fee includes the shipping cost.

Q: Can I sell both handmade products and clothing on Etsy? A: Yes, Etsy is known for its wide range of offerings, including handmade products, crafts, vintage items, as well as clothing and accessories.

Q: Do Etsy and Poshmark have different target audiences? A: Yes, Etsy primarily attracts customers looking for unique and handmade items, while Poshmark's target audience is primarily interested in clothing, sneakers, and fashion accessories.

Q: Is it worth cross-listing items on Etsy and Poshmark? A: Cross-listing can be beneficial as it expands your potential customer base. However, it is essential to consider the fees and limitations of each platform before deciding to cross-list.

Q: Are there any hidden fees on Etsy that sellers should be aware of? A: While Etsy does have several additional fees, they are well-documented and transparent. It is crucial for sellers to familiarize themselves with all the fees to accurately calculate their profit margins.

Q: Can sellers offer free shipping on Etsy? A: Yes, sellers on Etsy can choose to offer free shipping. However, they need to consider the impact on their profit margins as they will incur the shipping costs themselves.

Q: Is Poshmark a suitable platform for selling digital items? A: Poshmark is primarily focused on physical fashion items and does not currently support the sale of digital products or downloads. Sellers looking to sell digital items should explore other platforms such as Etsy or specialized digital marketplaces.

Q: Can sellers set their own prices on Etsy and Poshmark? A: Yes, both Etsy and Poshmark allow sellers to set their own prices for their products. However, it is essential to consider the fees and profitability when setting prices to ensure a reasonable profit margin.

I am a ETSY merchant, I am opening several ETSY stores. I use Etsyshop to find ETSY stores and track competitor stores. Etsyshop really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to Etsyshop's service, I hope more people can like Etsyshop! — Ecomvy

Join Etsyshop to find the ETSY store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
ETSY Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial
Browse More Content