Boost Your Online Business: Etsy vs Squarespace

Boost Your Online Business: Etsy vs Squarespace

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Understanding Etsy
  3. Pros of Selling on Etsy
    • Low barrier to entry
    • Immediate exposure to a large audience
    • User-friendly platform
    • SEO and keyword research for better visibility
  4. Cons of Selling on Etsy
    • High competition in popular niches
    • Price gouging and plagiarism
    • Accumulation of fees as the business grows
    • Algorithm changes dictated by Etsy
  5. Exploring Squarespace
  6. Pros of Selling on Squarespace
    • User-friendly website building tools
    • Complete control over branding and customization
    • Engaged audience retention
    • Ideal for established businesses with an existing audience
  7. Cons of Selling on Squarespace
    • Need to bring your own audience
    • Higher initial investment for the website
    • Additional work for shipping arrangements
    • SEO challenges for driving traffic
  8. Alternatives to Consider
    • Amazon Handmade
    • eBay
    • Fair and Dough for wholesale options
  9. Conclusion

Etsy vs. Squarespace: Choosing the Right Platform for Your Online Store

Are you an aspiring entrepreneur looking to start an online store? If so, you might be faced with the dilemma of choosing between Etsy and Squarespace. Both platforms offer unique advantages and cater to different types of businesses. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of selling on Etsy and Squarespace, helping you make an informed decision based on your specific needs and goals.

Understanding Etsy

Etsy is a renowned online marketplace catering to handmade, vintage, and unique goods. It provides a platform for artisans, creators, and small businesses to showcase and sell their products to a wide audience. With a low barrier to entry, Etsy allows individuals to start their online stores with ease. The platform offers exposure to millions of potential customers, making it an attractive option for those without an existing audience.

Pros of Selling on Etsy

One of the key advantages of Etsy is its low barrier to entry. When you first start, you are given 10 free listings, which is an excellent opportunity to test the market and gain visibility without spending money. Additionally, Etsy's user-friendly interface makes it easy to set up and manage your online store. You can effortlessly navigate through your stats and analytics, create sales and discounts, and personalize your shop to reflect your brand.

Furthermore, Etsy provides immediate exposure to a vast audience. With millions of people browsing the platform regularly, you can tap into a ready-made customer base interested in handmade and unique products. This exposure eliminates the need to build an audience from scratch and allows you to reach potential customers who may not have discovered your products otherwise.

To maximize your visibility on Etsy, it is crucial to conduct SEO and keyword research. By optimizing your product listings with relevant keywords and descriptions, you increase your chances of ranking higher in search results, attracting more potential customers, and generating sales. Etsy's algorithm rewards well-optimized listings, giving you a competitive edge.

Cons of Selling on Etsy

Despite its advantages, Etsy also has its drawbacks. One of the major challenges is the high competition in popular niches. If you are a seller of art prints, for example, you may face a saturated market with several competitors offering similar products. This high competition can make it more challenging to stand out and attract customers solely within the Etsy platform.

Another concern for Etsy sellers is the prevalence of price gouging and plagiarism. As the platform attracts a large number of sellers, some unethical individuals may copy or imitate your products, compromising your originality and undermining your hard work. It is crucial to constantly monitor and protect your intellectual property rights to ensure fair competition.

Additionally, Etsy's fees can accumulate as your business grows. While the initial barrier to entry is low, listing fees, re-listing fees, Etsy fees, and shipping fees can add up, especially for busier shops. These fees may impact your profit margins, and it is essential to factor them into your pricing strategy and financial planning.

Furthermore, Etsy's algorithm changes periodically, and as a seller, you must adapt to these changes. This lack of control over the platform's dynamics can be frustrating, as you need to adjust your strategies to meet the new requirements, whether it's updating your product listings or modifying your SEO approach. This external influence on your business can limit your autonomy and hinder long-term planning.

Exploring Squarespace

While Etsy caters to a specific type of online store, Squarespace offers a more holistic solution for creating and managing your website. Squarespace provides user-friendly website building tools that allow you to design a professional and customizable online store. Unlike Etsy, Squarespace requires you to bring your own audience, making it more suitable for businesses with an established following.

Pros of Selling on Squarespace

One of the significant advantages of Squarespace is its user-friendly interface. Whether you are an experienced web designer or a beginner, Squarespace's intuitive platform makes it accessible to create and maintain a visually appealing website. It offers a wide range of customizable templates, allowing you to tailor the design to match your brand aesthetic.

Furthermore, by using Squarespace, you have complete control over your branding and customization. Unlike Etsy, where you have limited options for personalization, Squarespace enables you to choose your colors, fonts, and overall site layout. This level of customization helps you create a cohesive and unique brand identity that resonates with your target audience.

Squarespace is an ideal platform for businesses with an existing engaged audience. If you already have a dedicated following on social media, a thriving email list, or a strong presence on another platform, Squarespace allows you to bring that audience directly to your website. By consolidating your online presence, you can maintain your listeners, viewers, or customers within your site, presenting them with a cohesive brand experience.

An often overlooked advantage of Squarespace is its exceptional customer service. If you encounter any difficulties or have questions while building and managing your website, Squarespace's customer support team is readily available to assist you. Their reliable support ensures that you have access to expert guidance whenever you need it, providing peace of mind as you navigate the complexities of running an online store.


In conclusion, choosing between Etsy and Squarespace depends on various factors, including your target audience, level of brand engagement, and customization requirements. If you are just starting out and do not have a significant audience, Etsy might be the best platform to gain exposure and take advantage of its low barrier to entry. On the other hand, if you have an engaged audience and want more control over your brand and website, Squarespace offers a user-friendly and customizable solution.

Before making a decision, thoroughly evaluate your business goals, audience engagement, and resources. Consider other alternatives such as Amazon Handmade or eBay for different selling approaches. Ultimately, choose the platform that aligns with your vision and enables you to create a successful online presence for your business.

Are you spending too much time looking for products?
App rating
Trending Product
Trusted Customers

Etsyshop has the world's largest selection of ETSY store to choose from, and each product has a large number of ETSY products, so you can choose ETSY store & product for your Ecommerce and dropshipping business without any hassle.

Browse More Content