Avoid These Etsy Mistakes!

Avoid These Etsy Mistakes!

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction
  2. Mistake #1: Not taking enough photos
  3. Mistake #2: Changing a best-selling item
  4. Mistake #3: Copyright or trademark infringement
  5. Mistake #4: Unprofessional responses to reviews
  6. Mistake #5: Underpricing your products
  7. Mistake #6: Focusing on the wrong niche
  8. Mistake #7: Utilizing Etsy ads at the wrong time
  9. Mistake #8: Copying the competition
  10. Mistake #9: Setting it and forgetting it
  11. Mistake #10: Not starting


The 10 Biggest Etsy Mistakes That Could be Hurting Your Sales

In the world of online marketplaces, Etsy has become a popular platform for creative entrepreneurs to sell their handmade products. With over 5,000 sales and $75,000 in revenue, I have learned a great deal from my own experiences on Etsy. Along the way, I have made mistakes and noticed others making the same ones that could be costing them sales, money, time, and hindering their path to success. In this article, I will discuss the ten biggest Etsy mistakes and how you can avoid them to maximize your shop's potential. So let's dive right in and learn from these common pitfalls.

Mistake #1: Not taking enough photos

Visual appeal plays a crucial role in attracting potential customers, and this applies to online shopping as well. With the advancement of technology, people now expect to see multiple photos and even videos of products they are interested in. Therefore, it is essential to provide as many high-quality images as possible. Even if you operate a print-on-demand shop, finding ways to showcase important information through photos can be beneficial. Include specifications, sizing details, customization options, or even how-to-order guides within your product photos. By doing so, you can engage customers and provide them with the necessary information without solely relying on text descriptions.

Mistake #2: Changing a best-selling item

Etsy's search algorithm can be unpredictable at times, making it risky to make drastic changes to items that are already performing well. When you modify a listing, it takes Etsy some time to index and update the changes in search results. During this period, the listing may become temporarily unavailable or lose visibility to potential customers. To avoid unnecessary disruptions in sales, it is advisable to stagger out updates and test new elements using a technique called A/B testing. Instead of directly modifying a successful listing, create a duplicate with the desired changes and compare its performance against the original. This way, you can make informed decisions based on data and optimize your sales without risking a sudden drop in visibility.

Mistake #3: Copyright or trademark infringement

Though tempting, engaging in copyright or trademark infringement is not worth the consequences. It is crucial to build a business that remains sustainable in the long run. Selling products that violate intellectual property rights puts your shop at risk of being shut down abruptly. Regardless of whether you create items from scratch or personally design art pieces featuring popular characters, using intellectual property that does not belong to you poses a significant legal risk. Even if you manage to operate undetected for a while, the constant fear of possible shutdown looms over your entrepreneurial journey. To establish a solid business foundation, focus on creating original, unique products that do not infringe on any copyrights or trademarks.

Mistake #4: Unprofessional responses to reviews

Receiving negative reviews can be disheartening, but responding unprofessionally is detrimental to your shop's reputation. It is important to remember that reviews are subjective opinions and not personal attacks. Treating all customers with respect and courtesy, even in less favorable situations, is crucial for the long-term success of your business. If you encounter a negative review, the best approach is to apologize for any dissatisfaction and assure the customer that you are available for further assistance via email or Etsy messages. Avoid indulging in detailing the customer's perceived wrongdoings or airing grievances. Potential customers who come across unprofessional responses may be dissuaded from making a purchase. Therefore, maintaining a polite and understanding tone in all interactions is essential.

Mistake #5: Underpricing your products

Competing solely on price is rarely a successful strategy, especially on a platform like Etsy. While it is understandable to feel pressured to lower prices to compete with other sellers, this often leads to undervaluing your products and potentially incurring losses. Instead, focus on pricing your items based on their value and quality. Consider whether the price aligns with your ability to sell the product successfully. Increasing prices may even lead to higher profits, as fewer sales can still yield the same or even better income with less effort. Ultimately, it is crucial to find a balance between competitive pricing and adequately valuing your products.

Mistake #6: Focusing on the wrong niche

Finding the right niche is essential for any online business, including Etsy shops. Many new shop owners struggle to get sales because they fail to explore different niches and find their points of leverage. Initially, it is important to experiment and explore various product categories, testing what resonates with your potential customer base. Once you identify a niche that shows promise, it is crucial to focus on exploiting it by narrowing your product range and doubling down on what works best. Instead of exclusively imitating successful shops, strive to stand out and make a lasting impression on potential customers. Conduct thorough research on your niche, analyze your competitors, and identify elements that set you apart. Utilize different colors, settings, or unique approaches to photography to capture attention and differentiate yourself from the crowded market.

Mistake #7: Utilizing Etsy ads at the wrong time

Etsy ads can be a useful tool for gaining visibility, but timing plays a vital role in their effectiveness. It is important to understand the seasonality of your business and adjust your ad strategy accordingly. For example, if you sell Christmas ornaments, investing in Etsy ads during the summer months might yield limited results due to a lack of demand. Before allocating your budget to ads, consider the search volume and overall sales trends for your products. By aligning your ad campaigns with peak seasons and relevant buying periods, you can optimize their impact and reach the right audience at the right time. Conduct thorough research and understand when your target audience is most likely to engage with your products before utilizing Etsy ads.

Mistake #8: Copying the competition

While it may seem tempting to imitate successful shops in your niche, standing out is crucial for long-term success. Instead of replicating their products or mimicking their photography style, focus on creating a unique and captivating brand identity. Take the time to analyze the competition and identify elements that set you apart. Explore different colors, packaging, or thematic approaches to attract attention and induce curiosity in potential customers. By providing a fresh and distinctive experience, you increase your chances of standing out amidst a sea of similar products.

Mistake #9: Setting it and forgetting it

Unlike a traditional brick-and-mortar business, an Etsy shop requires regular attention and adaptation to remain relevant. The marketplace's algorithm, popular search terms, and customer preferences are constantly changing. To ensure sustained success, it is crucial to stay up-to-date with trends and continually evolve your shop. Take the time to browse Etsy as a potential customer would, search for keywords related to your niche, and observe what successful listings are doing right. Make note of any new tags or strategies that you can implement to optimize your SEO and stay in line with the ever-changing landscape of the platform.

Mistake #10: Not starting

Perhaps the most significant mistake of all is not starting your Etsy shop due to various reasons and excuses. If you have a dream or a business idea, it is essential to take action and make it happen. While life circumstances may seem overwhelming, finding a way to pursue your passion is crucial. Time management and prioritization are key, and it is essential to remember that there will never be a perfect moment to start. Procrastination and hesitancy only hinder your progress. Embrace the fact that we only have one life and one shot at pursuing our dreams. Take that leap of faith and create the Etsy shop you have been dreaming of.

In conclusion, by identifying and avoiding these ten common mistakes, aspiring Etsy entrepreneurs can increase their chances of success on the platform. From taking enough photos and avoiding copyright infringements to embracing uniqueness and staying adaptable, each step plays a significant role in building a thriving business. Remember, every mistake is an opportunity to learn, grow, and refine your strategies for long-term success on Etsy.


  • Avoid the mistake of not taking enough photos to attract visual shoppers.
  • Be cautious about changing a best-selling item without properly assessing the impact on search rankings.
  • Respect copyright and trademark laws to avoid facing a sudden and permanent shop shutdown.
  • Respond professionally to all reviews, even if they are negative, to maintain a positive shop reputation.
  • Price your products appropriately to reflect their value and contribution to your business.
  • Focus on finding the right niche and standing out rather than copying competitors.
  • Optimize Etsy ads by aligning them with peak seasons and relevant buying periods.
  • Embrace uniqueness and create a memorable brand identity to differentiate yourself from the competition.
  • Continuously adapt and evolve your Etsy shop to align with trends and changing customer preferences.
  • Don't let excuses hold you back - take the leap and start your Etsy shop today.


Q: Can I use photos from other sources for my Etsy listings?

A: It is essential to create original visuals for your Etsy listings to ensure compliance with copyright laws. Using photos from other sources without proper permissions can lead to legal consequences and potential shop removal.

Q: Should I respond to negative reviews on Etsy?

A: Yes, responding to negative reviews is a crucial part of maintaining a professional image and resolving customer issues. By addressing concerns with courtesy and empathy, you can demonstrate your commitment to customer satisfaction.

Q: How often should I update my Etsy shop?

A: Regular updates are essential to keep your shop fresh and aligned with current trends. Review and optimize your listings, tags, and overall shop appearance periodically to stay competitive and relevant within your niche.

Q: How can I differentiate myself from similar sellers on Etsy?

A: To stand out from the competition, focus on developing a unique brand identity. Experiment with colors, packaging, and unconventional approaches to photography or design. Emphasize your distinct selling points to attract customers seeking something different.

Q: Is it worth investing in Etsy ads?

A: Etsy ads can be an effective tool for increasing visibility and driving traffic to your shop. However, it is crucial to consider the timing and relevance of your ad campaigns to maximize their impact. Research your target audience's habits and align your ads with relevant buying periods for optimal results.

Are you spending too much time looking for products?
App rating
Trending Product
Trusted Customers

Etsyshop has the world's largest selection of ETSY store to choose from, and each product has a large number of ETSY products, so you can choose ETSY store & product for your Ecommerce and dropshipping business without any hassle.

Browse More Content