Unboxing a Mysterious Makeup Box from Etsy!

Unboxing a Mysterious Makeup Box from Etsy!

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction
  2. Unboxing the Mystery Box
  3. The Bronzer and Contour Disaster
  4. Finding the Right Blush
  5. Let's Highlight, But Not Too Much
  6. The Eyebrow Saga
  7. Delving into the Eyeshadow Palette
  8. Experimenting with Blue Eyeliner
  9. The Mediocre Mascara
  10. The Lip Dilemma
  11. The Final Verdict and Removal


Unveiling the Mysteries of a Makeup Mystery Box


Have you ever been enticed by the allure of a mystery box? The anticipation of not knowing what treasures (or disappointments) lie within, waiting to be unboxed, is enough to pique anyone's curiosity. In this article, we will delve into the world of makeup mystery boxes and uncover the surprises, both pleasant and not-so-pleasant, that await inside.

Unboxing the Mystery Box

As we eagerly open the cute little box, adorned with a ribbon, we find ourselves face-to-face with the promise of a full face of makeup. Intriguingly named "My Cute Mystery Box," this seller on Etsy claims to have packed everything we need, except for foundation, which is understandably impossible to determine without knowing our individual shades. With a cost of 45 pounds, including delivery and VAT, expectations start to build.

The Bronzer and Contour Disaster

Our journey begins with a bronzer and contour product from Revolution Pro's Glam Mood Face Palette in the shade Deep. However, for the palest among us, this product proves to be a mismatch. The packaging itself displays signs of wear, with marks and imperfections abound. Despite its unassuming appearance, the formula fails to blend seamlessly, leaving a patchy and displeasing finish on the skin.

Finding the Right Blush

Moving on, we search for a suitable blush to add a touch of color to our cheeks. Our eyes land on a palette from the brand "The Two," adorned with blush shades in various hues. Opting for the middle matte pink shade, we cautiously apply it, and surprisingly, it complements our complexion quite well. The finely milled formula provides a pleasant pop of color without appearing overwhelming.

Let's Highlight, But Not Too Much

A makeup look is incomplete without a touch of highlighter to accentuate our features. We find ourselves presented with two options: a vibrant yellow-gold highlighter in a pineapple-shaped packaging and a lighter shade in a separate compact. Opting for the latter, we discover a subtle yet effective highlight that catches the light beautifully. The pineapple-shaped highlighter, however, proves to be far too intense for our liking.

The Eyebrow Saga

In the absence of a suitable eyebrow product, we venture into uncharted territory. With a clever improvisation using the bronzer, we attempt to fill in our eyebrows. While the results are not perfect, a bit of patience and perseverance yield a somewhat decent outcome. However, the lack of a dedicated eyebrow product is a glaring omission in this mystery box.

Delving into the Eyeshadow Palette

An eyeshadow palette is a crucial component of any makeup routine, and this mystery box does not disappoint in providing one. However, much to our surprise, the palette boasts an array of vibrant, orange and pink hues that do not align with our personal preferences. Despite this deviation from our comfort zone, the eyeshadows prove to be blendable and buildable, showcasing their quality regardless of their vibrant nature.

Experimenting with Blue Eyeliner

Brace yourself for a twist, as we encounter a blue liquid eyeliner, a departure from the conventional black or brown. Revolution Pro's Rockstar Matte Liquid Eyeliner challenges our expectations, but surprisingly, it applies smoothly and holds up throughout the day. While the color may not be everyone's cup of tea, the formula proves to be reliable, making a case for experimentation and stepping outside our comfort zones.

The Mediocre Mascara

Glam of Sweden's Volume Express Mascara enters the stage, presenting itself as an unknown contender. With a wand that rivals the thickness of our lashes, we apply the mascara with cautious optimism. However, the formula fails to impress, delivering average results that neither enhance nor transform our lashes. It lacks the va-va-voom factor we hoped for, leaving us wanting more.

The Lip Dilemma

The realm of lip products in this mystery box proves to be a rollercoaster of emotions. We begin with a burgundy lip liner from Revolution's Renaissance collection. Sadly, the product arrives in a slightly squished state, making application less than ideal. Furthermore, the accompanying lip color, Revlon's Color Stay Suede Ink Liquid Lipstick in the shade Tunnel Vision, veers far too pink for our taste. Despite their less-than-ideal colors, both products exhibit quality application and longevity.

The Final Verdict and Removal

With a coated layer of Revolution Pro's Crystal Gloss in the shade Absolutely, our lips receive an unexpected glossy finish with a touch of sparkle. While the final addition of this clear lip gloss may not be for everyone, it does live up to its promise of providing a shiny, glittery effect. As we conclude our makeup journey, we reflect on the overall experience of the mystery box. While some products did not align with our preferences, they showcased their quality, leaving room for exploration and experimentation.

In hindsight, the vast array of products and the delightful surprises inside the mystery box highlighted the beauty of venturing beyond comfort zones. While not everything was a perfect match, the process of unboxing and discovering new products offered a unique and exciting experience.

As we bid farewell to our makeup masterpiece, it's time to cleanse and remove the products that transformed us into unfamiliar faces. Despite the ups and downs, this makeup adventure has broadened our horizons and ignited a desire to explore even more mysterious beauty endeavors in the future.


  • Unveiling the surprises of a makeup mystery box
  • The hit and miss of product quality and suitability
  • Stepping outside comfort zones with vibrant eyeshadows and unconventional blue eyeliner
  • The importance of dedicated eyebrow products
  • Exploring the world of lip products with unforeseen challenges
  • Overall reflection on the mystery box experience and the joy of discovery


Q: Are mystery boxes worth the investment? A: Mystery boxes can be an exciting way to discover new products and brands. However, the value depends on personal preferences and the reputation of the seller. It's essential to research and read reviews before making a purchase.

Q: Can you customize the products in a makeup mystery box? A: In most cases, the products in a makeup mystery box are pre-selected and cannot be customized. The element of surprise is a significant aspect of the experience.

Q: Do makeup mystery boxes contain full-size products? A: Makeup mystery boxes can contain a mix of full-size and sample-size products. The exact contents vary depending on the brand and package purchased.

Are you spending too much time looking for products?
App rating
Trending Product
Trusted Customers

Etsyshop has the world's largest selection of ETSY store to choose from, and each product has a large number of ETSY products, so you can choose ETSY store & product for your Ecommerce and dropshipping business without any hassle.

Browse More Content