Unbiased Review: Etsy's Star Seller Program and How It Affects You

Unbiased Review: Etsy's Star Seller Program and How It Affects You

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. The Etsy Star Seller Program
    1. Summary of the Program
    2. Benefits and Features
    3. Updates and Changes
  3. Pros and Cons of the Star Seller Program
    1. Pros
    2. Cons
  4. Criteria for Qualification
    1. On-Time Shipping and Tracking
    2. Response Rate
    3. Five-Star Rating
    4. Order Value and Amount
  5. Concerns and Issues
    1. Cancelled Orders and Refunding
    2. Search Ranking
    3. Vacation Mode
    4. Digital Products
  6. General Thoughts and Feedback on the Star Seller Program
  7. Conclusion

The Etsy Star Seller Program: A Comprehensive Guide

Etsy, the beloved online marketplace for makers and handmade shop owners, has introduced the Etsy Star Seller program to reward shops that consistently deliver an excellent customer experience. This program aims to showcase and promote sellers who meet specific criteria and provide exceptional service to their customers. In this article, we will delve into the details of the Star Seller program, discuss its benefits and drawbacks, examine the qualification criteria, address concerns and issues raised by sellers, and provide our overall thoughts and feedback on this initiative. So grab a cup of coffee, sit back, and let's explore the world of Etsy Star Sellers together.

The Etsy Star Seller Program

Summary of the Program

The Etsy Star Seller program was developed by Etsy to recognize and reward shops that excel in providing a top-notch customer experience. To become a Star Seller, shops must meet certain criteria based on four main areas: on-time shipping and tracking, response rate, five-star rating, and order value and amount. By fulfilling these criteria, sellers not only earn a special Star Seller badge for buyers to see but also increase their chances of being featured by Etsy on the platform. The program, which was announced in July, has already undergone updates based on seller feedback and is likely to continue evolving.

Benefits and Features

One of the positive aspects of the Star Seller program is Etsy's willingness to listen to seller feedback and make changes accordingly. Although not perfect, Etsy acknowledges the need for improvement and demonstrates a commitment to addressing the issues that arise. This shows that Etsy values its sellers and aims to create a program that works well for everyone involved.

From a customer's perspective, the Star Seller program makes sense as it helps them identify reliable and reputable sellers. Customers can feel reassured knowing that shops with the Star Seller badge are responsive, have excellent reviews, and ship items on time. This feature enhances the overall shopping experience on Etsy by minimizing the risk of purchasing from sellers who may not deliver a satisfactory customer experience.

However, there are also concerns surrounding the program, which we will discuss further in the next section.

Pros and Cons of the Star Seller Program


One significant advantage of the Star Seller program is Etsy's responsiveness to seller feedback. Although there may be room for improvement, Etsy's willingness to make changes based on seller input is commendable. Sellers appreciate being heard and feel valued when their concerns are taken into account. This aspect of the program demonstrates Etsy's dedication to creating a platform that works well for both sellers and buyers.

Furthermore, the Star Seller badge can serve as a positive signal to customers, indicating that a shop offers a high level of customer service. This badge may encourage customers to choose Star Sellers over other shops, potentially leading to increased sales and revenue. Etsy's emphasis on rewarding excellent customer service is beneficial for both sellers and buyers, as it fosters trust and confidence in the platform.


Despite its positive aspects, the Star Seller program has some drawbacks that have raised concerns among Etsy sellers. One significant issue is the requirement for on-time shipping and tracking. While this criterion may seem reasonable, it poses challenges for sellers who operate in local markets where orders are often picked up instead of being shipped out. Such sellers are penalized under the current system because Etsy does not consider local pickup as shipping on time. Etsy has acknowledged this issue and is working on a solution to allow sellers to tag orders as pickups, thus counting them towards Star Seller qualification.

Another concern relates to the use of trackable shipping and the impact on pricing and conversion rates. Many customers are unwilling to pay for expensive tracking options, and sellers may be forced to increase prices to accommodate for the policy. This raises the question of whether the Star Seller badge alone is compelling enough for customers to justify paying higher prices. The potential negative effect on conversion rates due to increased prices is also a valid concern for sellers.

The Star Seller program's requirements for free shipping and trackable shipping clash with each other. On one hand, Etsy encourages sellers to offer free shipping on orders over a certain amount by providing search result placement benefits. On the other hand, the program emphasizes the use of trackable shipping, which can be expensive and impact pricing. This contradiction puts sellers in a difficult position, forcing them to either absorb the higher cost of trackable shipping, eliminate free shipping, or raise prices to accommodate both requirements.

These are just a few of the concerns raised by sellers regarding the Star Seller program. In the following sections, we will delve deeper into the specific criteria for qualification and address these concerns in more detail.

Criteria for Qualification

The Star Seller program has specific criteria that sellers must meet to qualify for the Star Seller badge. These criteria are assessed monthly, based on the shop's performance over the past three months. Let's take a closer look at each criterion and the challenges they present.

On-Time Shipping and Tracking

To be a Star Seller, sellers must ensure that 95% or more of their orders ship within the stated processing time, accompanied by tracking or shipping labels purchased from Etsy. For sellers within the US, tracking or an Etsy shipping label is required for all orders, with some exceptions for sellers in Canada, the UK, Australia, or Europe. However, local pickup orders pose a challenge as they are not currently considered on-time shipping by Etsy. The company is working on a solution to allow sellers to tag pickup orders, ensuring they count towards Star Seller qualification. Additionally, the requirement for trackable shipping may lead to higher prices for customers, potentially affecting conversion rates and profitability.

Response Rate

Another criterion to qualify as a Star Seller is maintaining a high response rate. Sellers must respond to 95% or more of initial buyer messages within 24 hours. While this may seem demanding, Etsy exempts messages initiated by Etsy staff and considers auto-reply messages as a response. Using saved replies and the Etsy app can help sellers manage their response rate effectively. However, the program's emphasis on constant availability can place additional stress on sellers and may undermine work-life balance.

Five-Star Rating

The Star Seller program highlights the importance of five-star ratings, requiring that 95% or more of a seller's reviews be five stars. However, sellers often face frustration when customers leave stellar written reviews but award only four stars. Etsy acknowledges this issue but currently considers five-star ratings necessary to qualify as a Star Seller. This requirement may disadvantage sellers who receive exceptional reviews but do not meet the specific rating criteria.

Order Value and Amount

To qualify for the Star Seller badge, sellers must fulfill the threshold of at least 10 orders over the last three months and achieve a minimum sales amount set by Etsy. The minimum sales amount varies depending on the seller's location, ensuring a fair bar for shops with different pricing structures. However, this criterion may pose challenges for sellers with low-priced items who must sell a significant quantity to meet the minimum sales amount. Similarly, sellers with high-priced items may struggle to reach the minimum order requirement of 10. Balancing pricing and sales volume becomes crucial for meeting these criteria effectively.

In the next section, we will address additional concerns and issues raised by sellers in relation to the Star Seller program.

(Continued in the full article)

Are you spending too much time looking for products?
App rating
Trending Product
Trusted Customers

Etsyshop has the world's largest selection of ETSY store to choose from, and each product has a large number of ETSY products, so you can choose ETSY store & product for your Ecommerce and dropshipping business without any hassle.

Browse More Content