Honest Review: Viewer's Print on Demand T-Shirt Shop

Honest Review: Viewer's Print on Demand T-Shirt Shop

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Importance of an Etsy Shop Banner
  3. Optimizing Thumbnail Designs
  4. Framing Designs for Maximum Visibility
  5. Getting the First Product Review
  6. Pricing Strategies
  7. Running Sales and Promotions
  8. Standing Out Amongst Competition
  9. Utilizing Color and Size Variations
  10. Conclusion


Welcome to this episode of Etsy Print-on-Demand Shop Reviews! In today's video, we will be evaluating a shop that reflects the journey many beginners go through on Etsy. This shop owner has followed my tutorials and guidance, and it will be interesting to see if they have implemented best practices effectively. We will also discuss the importance of small optimizations that can make a significant difference in attracting customers and making that crucial first sale. So let's dive in and analyze this shop together!

Importance of an Etsy Shop Banner

Having an eye-catching shop banner is fundamental for creating a cohesive and professional appearance for your Etsy shop. Although customers may not frequently visit your shop's homepage, it still plays a significant role in shaping their perception. Hence, it is essential to spend a few seconds creating an appealing shop banner. Websites like Pexels, where you can find royalty-free images, can be a great resource for selecting a suitable banner image. Adding a banner will complete your shop's look and potentially enhance the customer experience.

Optimizing Thumbnail Designs

When it comes to attracting customers, the design of your product thumbnails is crucial. Customers on platforms like Etsy often make split-second decisions based on the visual appeal of the thumbnail image. To ensure maximum visibility and improved click-through rates, it is recommended to frame your design to occupy at least 50% of the primary thumbnail space. You can achieve this by cropping and zooming your design using tools like Photoshop or online alternatives such as Photopea. By making these small optimizations, you can distinguish your listings from competitors and capture customers' attention more effectively.

Framing Designs for Maximum Visibility

Customers instinctively focus on images when browsing online platforms. Since we are accustomed to seeing product images in small squares, it is crucial to frame your designs prominently within the thumbnail space. By occupying a significant portion of the thumbnail with your design, you allow customers to quickly grasp the essence of your product, thus increasing the chances of them clicking on your listing. Utilizing this strategy consistently across all your listings will contribute to creating a strong brand presence and enhancing customer perception.

Getting the First Product Review

The first product review holds immense significance for a shop. Even a single review can significantly impact your click-through rate and conversion rate. To overcome the initial hurdle of obtaining the first review, consider creating a product listing for a low-cost digital download. This allows you to reach out to friends or family members and request them to make a purchase and leave a review. Even a single review can make a significant difference in how prospective customers perceive your shop. Remember, going from zero to one review is a crucial milestone that can influence customers' trust and confidence in your products.

Pricing Strategies

Pricing plays a crucial role in attracting customers and generating sales. While your current pricing at $19.95 is reasonable, you may consider increasing the sale price slightly and running sales. By offering a discounted price, you can leverage the psychological impact of "sale" messaging and create a sense of urgency. It is worth noting that many competitors are already implementing this strategy. By strategically selecting a sale price and including discount messaging, you can stand out among competitors and capture customers' attention.

Running Sales and Promotions

Running sales and promotions can significantly impact your conversion rate. Consider the extra element of color and attention that a sale badge brings to your listings. Even a small discount can influence customers' decision-making process, especially when faced with multiple options. By periodically offering sales, you increase your chances of attracting customers who are searching for deals or feeling compelled to make a purchase due to the perceived value offered during the sale period. Experimenting with various discount percentages or free shipping offers can help you identify the optimal strategy for your shop.

Standing Out Amongst Competition

To succeed on Etsy, it is crucial to differentiate yourself from competitors in your niche. As we discussed earlier, framing your design prominently in the thumbnail is essential. Additionally, you should analyze your competitors' listings and identify areas for improvement. By including more information or value propositions in your thumbnails, such as highlighting available color variations or unique features, you can create a stronger impact on potential customers. By consistently refining your listings based on customer preferences and optimizing your product presentation, you can position yourself as a standout seller in your niche.

Utilizing Color and Size Variations

Another strategy to gain a competitive edge is by offering color and size variations for specific listings. By providing a wide selection, you cater to the diverse preferences of customers and increase the chances of conversions. Additionally, you can create a sense of urgency by temporarily reducing the price of specific color and size variations, making them appear more enticing in search results. This approach makes your listings more visually appealing and increases the likelihood of customers clicking on your products.


In this evaluation of your shop, we have discussed several strategies that can help improve your Etsy shop's performance. By implementing best practices such as creating an appealing shop banner, optimizing thumbnail designs, obtaining the first product review, employing effective pricing strategies, running sales and promotions, standing out among competitors, and utilizing color and size variations, you can enhance customer engagement, increase conversion rates, and ultimately achieve greater success on Etsy. Remember to regularly evaluate and refine your shop to remain competitive in the ever-evolving e-commerce landscape. Good luck!

Are you spending too much time looking for products?
App rating
Trending Product
Trusted Customers

Etsyshop has the world's largest selection of ETSY store to choose from, and each product has a large number of ETSY products, so you can choose ETSY store & product for your Ecommerce and dropshipping business without any hassle.

Browse More Content