From Star Seller to Etsy Shutdown

From Star Seller to Etsy Shutdown

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. My Experience with YouTube and Etsy
  3. Pros and Cons of Etsy
  4. The Challenges of Selling Furniture on Etsy
  5. Tips for Selling on Etsy
    • 5.1. Simplifying Titles
    • 5.2. Shipping
    • 5.3. Customer Service
    • 5.4. Building an E-commerce Website
    • 5.5. Utilizing Social Media
  6. Alternatives to Etsy
  7. Conclusion

My Experience with YouTube and Etsy

Hey everybody, it's Casey here. I have been wanting to pick YouTube back up for a while now, but finding the time has been challenging. It takes up so much time, but I have decided to give multitasking a chance. Today, I want to talk to you about my experience with Etsy. In 2020, right after the pandemic hit, I started my Etsy shop, Mountain Cove Market. I primarily paint French furniture, but unfortunately, the style doesn't align with the preferences of the rural area I live in. My pieces weren't selling too well initially, and I struggled to flip furniture. That's when I decided to open an Etsy shop and things started to take off.

While my Etsy journey was successful for a few years, I encountered a major setback when my shop got shut down due to "suspicious activity". Despite not violating any of Etsy's rules, Etsy didn't provide any explanation or support. This experience made me question the reliability and stability of Etsy as a platform. I realized the importance of diversifying my sales channels and building my own e-commerce website. In this article, I will share the pros and cons of selling on Etsy, the challenges of selling furniture, and provide tips for navigating the platform. I will also explore alternative platforms for selling handmade goods. So let's dive in and explore the world of Etsy and beyond.

Pros and Cons of Etsy

Etsy, a popular online marketplace for handmade and vintage goods, offers several benefits for sellers. One of the main advantages is the large and established customer base that Etsy attracts. With millions of active buyers, Etsy provides exposure to a wide audience and allows sellers to reach customers worldwide. Additionally, Etsy takes care of the technical aspects of running an online store, such as payment processing, listing management, and search engine optimization (SEO).

However, selling on Etsy also has its drawbacks. First and foremost, Etsy charges fees for listing items, transaction fees for each sale, and additional fees for advertising and promoted listings. These fees can significantly eat into a seller's profit margin, especially for low-priced items. Furthermore, Etsy's algorithm and policies can be unpredictable, leading to shop suspensions or listing removals without clear explanations. This lack of transparency and customer support has frustrated many sellers, who feel a sense of vulnerability and uncertainly about the future of their businesses.

The Challenges of Selling Furniture on Etsy

Selling furniture presents unique challenges on Etsy. Firstly, shipping large and heavy items like furniture can be a logistical nightmare. It requires careful packaging, arranging freight transportation, and ensuring the delivery process goes smoothly. Many sellers have to learn how to navigate the complexities of shipping and handle potential damages or returns.

Another challenge is standing out in a saturated market. Etsy is flooded with furniture sellers, making it difficult for individual sellers to differentiate themselves. Additionally, the tastes and preferences of Etsy's primarily millennial customer base may not align with more traditional or niche furniture styles. This discrepancy in preferences can impact sales and require sellers to adapt their product offerings to meet the demands of the market.

Finally, the competitive nature of the platform means sellers have to continuously optimize their listings and stay updated with trends and SEO strategies. It's essential to have compelling product descriptions, high-quality photographs, and effective use of keywords to rank higher in search results. Without proper SEO and marketing strategies, sellers may struggle to attract customers and generate sales.

Tips for Selling on Etsy

  1. Simplifying Titles: Based on my personal experience, simplifying titles can boost visibility and improve search rankings. Keyword research and strategic placement of relevant keywords in titles and product descriptions can help attract potential customers.

  2. Shipping: Developing a solid shipping strategy is crucial for selling furniture on Etsy. Researching different shipping options, carriers, and packaging materials can help you streamline the process and offer competitive shipping rates to customers. Consider offering free shipping or calculating shipping costs into the listing price to attract more buyers.

  3. Customer Service: Providing excellent customer service is essential for maintaining a strong reputation on Etsy. Responding promptly to customer inquiries, addressing concerns, and ensuring timely delivery are crucial factors for success. Building relationships with customers through personalized communication can lead to positive reviews and repeat business.

  4. Building an E-commerce Website: While Etsy is a popular platform, it's important to explore alternative sales channels, such as building your own e-commerce website. This allows you to have more control over your brand, margins, and customer relationships. Shopify, WordPress with WooCommerce, or platforms like SquareUp can be excellent options for creating your online store.

  5. Utilizing Social Media: Creating a strong presence on social media platforms like Pinterest and Instagram can attract a broader audience and drive traffic to your Etsy shop or website. Utilize these platforms to showcase your products, engage with potential customers, and build a loyal following.

Alternatives to Etsy

While Etsy is a popular choice for creatives, there are other platforms worth exploring. Here are a few alternatives:

  1. Shopify: Shopify is a comprehensive e-commerce platform that allows sellers to create their online stores from scratch. With various customizable templates, payment options, and built-in SEO features, Shopify offers a user-friendly and robust solution for selling handmade goods.

  2. Big Cartel: Big Cartel caters to independent artists and makers, offering a simple and intuitive platform to sell limited quantities of products. It's an excellent option for sellers who want to maintain a small-scale operation while having control over their branding and style.

  3. WordPress with WooCommerce: For sellers who prefer more control over their website's design and functionality, WordPress with WooCommerce is a popular choice. With numerous plugins and themes available, WooCommerce allows sellers to create a personalized and scalable online store.

  4. Artfire: Artfire is a marketplace specifically focused on handmade, artisan, and vintage products. It offers a wide range of categories and allows sellers to customize their shops and product listings.

Ultimately, finding the right platform depends on your specific needs and goals as a seller. Consider factors such as fees, audience demographics, ease of use, and branding opportunities when deciding where to sell your products.


Selling on Etsy can be a rewarding experience, but it's crucial to navigate the platform's challenges and be prepared for unexpected setbacks. Building an e-commerce website and exploring alternative sales channels can provide more stability and control over your business. Remember to invest in building your brand and utilize social media platforms to expand your reach. By diversifying your sales channels and staying adaptable to changes, you can create a thriving handmade goods business with a nationwide market.

Are you spending too much time looking for products?
App rating
Trending Product
Trusted Customers

Etsyshop has the world's largest selection of ETSY store to choose from, and each product has a large number of ETSY products, so you can choose ETSY store & product for your Ecommerce and dropshipping business without any hassle.

Browse More Content