Discover the Ultimate Etsy Review for MTG “Paper-Weight”

Discover the Ultimate Etsy Review for MTG “Paper-Weight”

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Background Story
  3. The Issue with Size
  4. The Quality of Craftsmanship
  5. Pricing and Value
  6. Comparison to Other Etsy Products
  7. Customer Reviews and Feedback
  8. The Seller's Response
  9. Conclusion
  10. Final Thoughts and Recommendations

Review of Schofield Studios' Etsy Products

Hey folks, it's Kevin again with the Basement Games. Today, I want to share my review of an Etsy product that recently arrived from Schofield Studios. However, before we dive into the details, I must mention that Schofield Studios no longer sells this particular item due to some complaints. Instead, there is a new seller named Years Fullfilled Studios that has taken over this product.

Background Story

As a magic collector and avid player of the game, I am always on the lookout for unique magic products. When I stumbled upon Schofield Studios' listing on Etsy, the pictures immediately caught my attention. They showcased a fascinating product, a replica of the iconic Lotus card, beautifully crafted with multiple layers to create a three-dimensional effect.

The Issue with Size

Upon receiving the product, I noticed one significant drawback. The size of the replica Lotus was smaller than I expected. Comparing it to a regular magic card, the difference was noticeable. While it wasn't gigantic, the 2/3 size of the replica was unexpected. This lack of full-size representation was somewhat disappointing.

The Quality of Craftsmanship

Despite the size issue, the replica Lotus was still done fairly well. Schofield Studios took a card replica, cut it out, layered it with epoxy, and created a captivating paperweight. The craftsmanship was evident in the attention to detail, resulting in a unique and visually appealing product. Schofield Studios specializes in creating nostalgic pieces, often incorporating references to popular video games like Zelda.

Pricing and Value

Now, let's discuss the pricing and value of these Etsy products. When I made my order, I also inquired about a custom order to display to interested customers. However, that's where the problem began. I received a custom order for a bacin, a commander card, which had a few glaring issues. Firstly, the logo on the card was from the From the Volt's Angels edition, taken from a non-foil picture online and printed without the original foiling that would enhance its appearance. This decision to use a non-foil image negatively impacted the overall quality of the product.

Comparison to Other Etsy Products

When comparing Schofield Studios' products to other similar items on Etsy, the discrepancies became evident. The lack of attention to detail in cutting the card, the imperfect alignment, and the amateurish edges diminished the overall quality. These issues were unexpected, considering the price of $60 for each item, which was higher than I anticipated. I firmly believe that for such a price, the product should have been of better quality.

Customer Reviews and Feedback

Unfortunately, I am not the only customer who expressed disappointment with the product. Several other buyers left reviews expressing similar concerns with the size, craftsmanship, and value for money. These reviews indicate a consistent pattern and raise questions about the product's overall quality.

The Seller's Response

Recently, Schofield Studios discontinued their Etsy store, perhaps due to the feedback they received. It is unfortunate that they decided to shut down instead of using the feedback to improve their products. Etsy is a platform known for unique, custom items and gifts, and it would have been more beneficial for them to address the issues raised by customers. It is worth noting that the new seller, Years Fullfilled Studios, has an opportunity to rectify these concerns and provide high-quality products that meet customers' expectations.


In conclusion, Schofield Studios' Etsy products, particularly the replica Lotus and the custom order bacin, fell short of expectations. The issues with size, craftsmanship, and value for money raised concerns among customers, leading the seller to close down the store. However, this presents an opportunity for the new seller, Years Fullfilled Studios, to learn from past mistakes and deliver improved products that satisfy the needs and preferences of magic collectors and players.

Final Thoughts and Recommendations

As a magic enthusiast, I believe there is a considerable demand for high-quality replicas and custom magic products on platforms like Etsy. Therefore, I encourage Years Fullfilled Studios, the new seller, to take the necessary steps to address the issues faced by previous buyers. By focusing on delivering accurate sizing, impeccable craftsmanship, and reasonable pricing, they have the potential to build a loyal customer base and establish themselves as a trusted seller in the magic community.


  • Schofield Studios' Etsy products, particularly the replica Lotus and custom order bacin, received mixed reviews.
  • Customers expressed concerns about the smaller size of the replica Lotus compared to regular magic cards.
  • Craftsmanship had some positive aspects, but certain flaws, such as imperfect cutting and amateurish edges, detracted from the overall quality.
  • The pricing of $60 per item was higher than expected for the level of quality provided.
  • Schofield Studios decided to shut down their Etsy store rather than addressing customer feedback.
  • The new seller, Years Fullfilled Studios, has an opportunity to rectify the issues and deliver improved products.


Q: Is the replica Lotus significantly smaller than regular magic cards?
A: Yes, the replica Lotus is approximately 2/3 the size of a regular magic card, leading to a noticeable difference in size.

Q: What were the issues with the craftsmanship of the custom order bacin?
A: The logo used on the bacin was taken from a non-foil image online, resulting in a lower quality appearance. Additionally, the cutting and alignment of the card were not done accurately, and the edges were somewhat amateurish.

Q: Why did Schofield Studios decide to close down their Etsy store?
A: It is unclear why Schofield Studios shut down their store, but it may have been a response to the feedback and complaints received from customers.

Q: Can Years Fullfilled Studios improve upon the previous issues?
A: Yes, there is an opportunity for the new seller to learn from the past and provide high-quality products that address the concerns raised by customers.

Are you spending too much time looking for products?
App rating
Trending Product
Trusted Customers

Etsyshop has the world's largest selection of ETSY store to choose from, and each product has a large number of ETSY products, so you can choose ETSY store & product for your Ecommerce and dropshipping business without any hassle.

Browse More Content