Avoid This Mistake When Selling on Etsy!

Avoid This Mistake When Selling on Etsy!

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction
  2. The Temptation of Being a Copycat 2.1. Copying Top Sellers on Etsy 2.2. The Consequences of Copying 2.3. Lack of Originality and Creativity
  3. Why Copycats Never Succeed 3.1. Being 10 Steps Behind 3.2. The Price Competition Dilemma 3.3. Customers Value Authenticity 3.4. Creating a Successful Shop
  4. The Unsustainability of Being a Copycat 4.1. Lack of Fulfillment and Joy 4.2. Playing the Price Game
  5. Moving Forward: Finding Inspiration 5.1. Balancing Inspiration and Originality 5.2. Building Your Own Brand and Identity
  6. The Reality of Copying 6.1. Market Leaders vs Copycats 6.2. The Outcome of Copycat Strategy
  7. Conclusion
  8. Stay Connected on Instagram 8.1. Daily Tactics and Tips 8.2. Follow @dylanjarris

Why the Copycats Never Win on Etsy


Etsy has become a thriving platform for creatives and entrepreneurs alike, offering a space to showcase and sell unique handmade and vintage products. However, in the pursuit of success, many sellers are tempted to take shortcuts by copying what top sellers are doing. In this article, we will explore why the copycat strategy never leads to long-term success on Etsy and why it's essential to find your own path to stand out in the crowded marketplace.

The Temptation of Being a Copycat

Copying Top Sellers on Etsy

When starting or growing a shop on Etsy, it's natural to look at the top sellers for inspiration. Their success is visible, and it can be tempting to replicate their strategies by taking their titles, tags, descriptions, and even photos. However, this approach is not only against Etsy's policies but also detrimental to your own business.

The Consequences of Copying

Copying other shops' work may provide short-term benefits, but it ultimately hinders your potential for success. Instead of creating original ideas and fostering creativity, copycat shops rely on riding on the coattails of established sellers. This strategy may seem appealing at first, but it only takes you so far before you hit a wall.

Lack of Originality and Creativity

One significant drawback of the copycat strategy is the lack of originality and creativity. By imitating others, you are always playing catch-up, never truly offering something unique or innovative. Customers are drawn to Etsy for its distinctiveness, seeking authentic, one-of-a-kind products. By copying, you rob yourself of the opportunity to build a brand that customers crave.

Why Copycats Never Succeed

Being 10 Steps Behind

Copycat shops are perpetually behind the trendsetters. By the time you spot a successful strategy from another shop and attempt to implement it, you are already months behind. To reach the million-dollar level on Etsy, you need to be proactive, anticipating customer needs, and staying ahead of the competition.

The Price Competition Dilemma

When you copy other shops, you inevitably fall into the price competition trap. To compete, you are forced to lower your prices, sacrificing your profit margins. However, competing solely on price limits your growth potential and prevents you from becoming a top-tier shop on Etsy.

Customers Value Authenticity

Etsy customers value more than just price; they seek quality, craftsmanship, and the overall customer experience. They want to support designers and artists and purchase unique, original pieces. By copying, you fail to deliver the real deal, and customers will eventually notice.

Creating a Successful Shop

To achieve success on Etsy, you must think beyond copying and focus on creating a strong brand. A million-dollar shop is built on a foundation of authenticity, originality, and anticipating customer desires. By offering something unique, you attract customers who appreciate your design aesthetic and craftsmanship.

The Unsustainability of Being a Copycat

Lack of Fulfillment and Joy

Running a successful business should be a fulfilling venture, where you can explore your own ideas and see them come to fruition. Being a copycat robs you of the joy of creating and testing your own concepts. True success lies in implementing your own ideas, not relying on someone else's.

Playing the Price Game

Continuing to copy other shops means perpetually playing the price game. This unsustainable strategy leads to lower profit margins and diminishes the value you can offer to customers. Eventually, this approach leads to burnout and disappointment.

Moving Forward: Finding Inspiration

Balancing Inspiration and Originality

While it's natural to seek inspiration from others, it's crucial to strike a balance between inspiration and originality. Use successful shops as a guide but always add your unique twist to stand out from the crowd.

Building Your Own Brand and Identity

The true measure of success is creating a brand so compelling that customers want to buy solely from you. Building your own identity sets you apart from the competition and establishes a loyal customer base. Focus on developing your brand's story, aesthetic, and exceptional customer experience.

The Reality of Copying

Market Leaders vs Copycats

To fully understand the consequences of copying, one only needs to examine the market leaders and the copycats. A quick search on Etsy will reveal that the top sellers have higher prices, more reviews, and a stronger presence. In contrast, the copycats struggle to gain traction, often priced lower and lacking sales and reviews.

The Outcome of Copycat Strategy

The copycat strategy ultimately fizzles out. It is not sustainable and stifles your potential for growth and success. By copying, you limit your ability to create a fulfilling business and hinder your chances of becoming a market leader.


In the competitive world of Etsy, it's easy to fall into the trap of copying other successful shops. However, the copycat strategy will never lead to long-term success. To thrive, you must embrace your creativity, focus on originality, and anticipate customer needs. Building a successful shop is about creating a brand that customers recognize and trust. So, stand out from the crowd, find your unique voice, and create a business that resonates with your target audience.

Stay Connected on Instagram

For daily tactics, tips, and inspiration, follow us on Instagram @dylanjarris. We share valuable insights to help you grow your Etsy business and navigate the ever-changing marketplace. Join our community today and take your shop to the next level.

Are you spending too much time looking for products?
App rating
Trending Product
Trusted Customers

Etsyshop has the world's largest selection of ETSY store to choose from, and each product has a large number of ETSY products, so you can choose ETSY store & product for your Ecommerce and dropshipping business without any hassle.

Browse More Content