Etsy Ads: The $500 Failure You Need to Know About

Etsy Ads: The $500 Failure You Need to Know About

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction
  2. Understanding Etsy Ads
  3. The Lack of Control in Etsy Ads
  4. The Numbers: Cost and Revenue
  5. Click-Through Rate and Keyword Optimization
  6. The Problem with Etsy's Algorithm
  7. The Balance between Relevant Tags and Ad Spending
  8. Managing Ad Campaigns on Etsy
  9. The Frustration of Moving Successful Products from Amazon to Etsy
  10. Conclusion

Understanding Etsy Ads and the Challenges Faced

In today's world of online selling, advertising plays a crucial role in promoting products and increasing their visibility. One such platform that offers advertising services to sellers is Etsy. However, the experience of using Etsy ads can be quite different compared to other platforms, like Amazon. In this article, we will explore the intricacies of Etsy ads, shed light on the challenges faced by sellers, and analyze the impact of advertising on their businesses.


Etsy, an e-commerce platform known for its handmade and vintage products, provides an advertising feature for sellers to boost their listings' visibility. These ads aim to increase exposure and drive traffic to sellers' products. However, the effectiveness of Etsy ads and the control given to sellers over their ad campaigns have been subjects of debate and frustration.

Understanding Etsy Ads

Before delving into the challenges associated with Etsy ads, let's first understand how they work. Etsy ads operate on a cost-per-click (CPC) model, where sellers pay for each click their ads receive. The ads are displayed prominently throughout Etsy's marketplace, reaching potential buyers who may not have otherwise come across the sellers' products.

The Lack of Control in Etsy Ads

Unlike platforms like Amazon, where sellers have control over their bids and keyword targeting, Etsy's advertising system offers little control to sellers. This lack of control has made many sellers feel like they are navigating a metaphorical "wild west" when it comes to Etsy ads. Unlike Amazon, Etsy does not allow sellers to adjust their bids or choose specific keywords for their ad campaigns.

The Numbers: Cost and Revenue

Despite the limited control over Etsy ads, many sellers continue to invest in them, hoping to generate revenue and profit. However, the results can be mixed. As shared by a seller in their experience with Etsy ads, they spent over $500 on ads for their new Etsy shop. Out of that expenditure, they generated $536 in revenue, resulting in a small profit. However, this revenue figure can be misleading since it does not account for the costs associated with fulfilling orders and shipping.

Click-Through Rate and Keyword Optimization

One of the critical factors affecting the success of Etsy ads is the click-through rate (CTR). An optimal CTR indicates that the ads are effectively capturing the attention of potential buyers. However, several sellers have reported low CTRs despite having high-quality product thumbnails and relevant listings. The reason behind this discrepancy lies in Etsy's algorithm and its handling of keyword targeting.

The Problem with Etsy's Algorithm

Etsy's algorithm, responsible for determining which keywords to target with ads, has been criticized for its seemingly flawed decision-making. In the example shared by the seller, it was observed that Etsy's algorithm was targeting irrelevant keywords, wasting valuable advertising budget. For instance, when the seller used the keyword "flat bill" for a hat listing, the algorithm spent money on keywords like "Bills fan," unrelated to the product.

The Balance between Relevant Tags and Ad Spending

To strike a balance between targeting the right audience organically and running successful ad campaigns, sellers need to be mindful of the keywords they include in their listings' tags. While relevant tags are essential for organic search visibility, incorporating too many keywords may result in Etsy's algorithm misinterpreting them and wasting ad spend on irrelevant keywords. Sellers must be cautious when selecting and optimizing their tags to avoid budget depletion due to poor keyword targeting.

Managing Ad Campaigns on Etsy

Though limited in its functionality, Etsy provides a tool for sellers to gain visibility into the keywords their ad campaigns are targeting. By accessing the "Search terms" section in the shop manager, sellers can review the keywords behind their ad spend and disable irrelevant keywords. This relatively straightforward process allows sellers to exercise some level of control over their ad campaigns' performance.

The Frustration of Moving Successful Products from Amazon to Etsy

One of the significant challenges faced by sellers is the difficulty in replicating their success on other platforms, such as Amazon, on Etsy. Sellers often assume that products performing well on Amazon will translate to success on Etsy as well. However, the limitations and quirks of Etsy's advertising system, as discussed earlier, can hinder the expected outcome, causing frustration and disappointment.


Etsy ads present sellers with an opportunity to increase their product visibility on the platform. While they can be effective in driving traffic and generating revenue, the lack of control over bid management and keyword targeting poses challenges for sellers. By understanding the intricacies of Etsy ads, sellers can optimize their campaigns, strike the right balance between relevant tags and ad spending, and navigate the platform more effectively. Despite the frustrations, Etsy continues to be a viable platform for sellers, but it requires careful attention and adaptation to the unique dynamics of the marketplace.


  • Etsy ads offer limited control over bid management and keyword targeting.
  • Sellers often face challenges with Etsy's algorithm, resulting in wasted ad spend on irrelevant keywords.
  • Optimization of tags is crucial to strike a balance between organic visibility and ad spending.
  • Sellers can manage their ad campaigns by reviewing and disabling irrelevant keywords.
  • Replicating success from other platforms on Etsy can be challenging due to the platform's unique dynamics.


Q: Can sellers adjust their bids and choose specific keywords in Etsy ads? A: No, Etsy ads do not provide sellers with control over their bid management and keyword targeting like platforms such as Amazon.

Q: How can sellers optimize their Etsy ad campaigns? A: Sellers can optimize their campaigns by reviewing the keywords their ads target and disabling irrelevant keywords in the shop manager.

Q: Can success on other platforms, such as Amazon, guarantee success on Etsy? A: No, success on other platforms does not always translate to success on Etsy due to the unique dynamics and limitations of Etsy's advertising system.

I am a ETSY merchant, I am opening several ETSY stores. I use Etsyshop to find ETSY stores and track competitor stores. Etsyshop really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to Etsyshop's service, I hope more people can like Etsyshop! — Ecomvy

Join Etsyshop to find the ETSY store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
ETSY Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial
Browse More Content