Discover Gorgeous Nail Polish Haul on Etsy

Discover Gorgeous Nail Polish Haul on Etsy

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. The Rise of Etsy for Nail Polish Shopping
  3. Exploring Whimsical Ideas by Pam
  4. Discovering Frankenstein and Heel Polishes
  5. Comet Vomit and its Unconventional Bottle
  6. Trying Black Dahlia Lacquer for the First Time
  7. Delving into Beefy Hope Cosmetics
  8. Sonoma Nail Art's Unique Offerings
  9. Pop Nail Polish's Ethereal Shades
  10. Jay Ryan Cosmetics: The Shifty Delight
  11. Exploring Splattered Paint Lacquer
  12. Mrs Smith's Multi-Chrome Magic
  13. Glitter by Erica: A Dark and Mysterious Choice
  14. Conclusion

The Ultimate Nail Polish Haul on Etsy

If you're a nail polish enthusiast always on the hunt for unique and indie brands, Etsy is the perfect destination for your shopping needs. In this ultimate nail polish haul, we dive into the world of Etsy and explore a wide range of brands that offer distinct and exceptional nail polishes. From established names to hidden gems, this article covers it all. So get ready to be mesmerized by the beautiful shades and finishes that the indie nail polish community has to offer.

The Rise of Etsy for Nail Polish Shopping

Etsy has become a go-to platform for nail polish enthusiasts looking for something different from mainstream brands. In the early days of indie polishes, Etsy was the hub for unique and innovative formulations. Today, the platform continues to thrive, hosting numerous shops that offer a variety of high-quality nail polishes. Let's embark on a journey to discover some of the best finds on Etsy and support independent sellers in the process.

Exploring Whimsical Ideas by Pam

One of the first brands that caught the attention of nail polish enthusiasts was Whimsical Ideas by Pam. Known for their iconic circular glitter polishes, Whimsical Ideas by Pam has continued to maintain its place in the indie polish community. With a unique ordering process, this brand offers polishes like "Sugar High," a white curly base loaded with semi-transparent rainbow glitters. Discover the whimsical world of Whimsical Ideas by Pam and add a touch of nostalgia to your nail polish collection.

Discovering Frankenstein and Heel Polishes

Frankenstein and Heel Polishes is a brand that offers a range of innovative nail polishes. Their attention to packaging and protection is commendable, with polishes arriving in plastic bags to prevent any spillage or accidents during transit. Get your hands on "Chuckles the Clown," a milky semi-sheer base with chunky rainbow glitters, or "Kaleidoscope," a mini polish with scattered holographic goodness. Experience the unique formulations and creative offerings of Frankenstein and Heel Polishes.

Comet Vomit and its Unconventional Bottle

Comet Vomit is a brand that pushes the boundaries of creativity. With unusual packaging choices, their polishes stand out from the crowd. Although the application process may be a bit tricky due to the long stem and small cap, the results are worth it. Dive into a night sky fantasy with "Dreamy Jelly Donuts," a milky off-white base filled with tiny red metallic glitters. Despite its unconventional appearance, Comet Vomit delivers stunning and vibrant nail polish shades.

Trying Black Dahlia Lacquer for the First Time

If you're looking to try a brand that combines aesthetics with top-notch formulas, Black Dahlia Lacquer is worth exploring. With its tall and thick bottle, this brand exudes quality and elegance. "Rosebud" offers a dusty blue curly base adorned with orange flakes and silver accents, while "Olaf Snow Flowers" provides a nude curly base with an abundance of holographic and gold glitters. Black Dahlia Lacquer adds a touch of sophistication to your nail polish collection.

Delving into Beefy Hope Cosmetics

For unique and vibrant shades, Beefy Hope Cosmetics is a must-try brand. "Of Gods and Goldfish" features an orange jelly base embellished with various sizes of orange glitters, creating a mesmerizing underwater effect. While the textured finish may require extra effort to remove, the beauty of this shade makes it worthwhile. Beefy Hope Cosmetics offers a range of stunning polishes that allow you to express your creativity and individuality.

Sonoma Nail Art's Unique Offerings

Sonoma Nail Art brings innovation and creativity to the indie polish scene. "Flipping Out" showcases a yellow-green base with metallic glitters and hexes, creating a bright and playful manicure. Explore the range of unique and unconventional shades offered by Sonoma Nail Art and add a pop of creativity to your nail polish rotation.

Pop Nail Polish's Ethereal Shades

Pop Nail Polish offers ethereal and mesmerizing shades that transport you to a fantastical realm. "Oh Good Lord, Before He Came Down It Never Snowed, And After It Did" captures the essence of a silvery icy blue sky, adorned with gold shimmer and iridescent flakies. While some flakies may require extra attention during application, the overall effect is truly enchanting. Dive into a world of whimsy with Pop Nail Polish and embrace the magic on your fingertips.

Jay Ryan Cosmetics: The Shifty Delight

Jay Ryan Cosmetics offers a holographic polish like no other. "Calliope" is a truly shifty shade that transitions between green, gold, and red, depending on the lighting. The multi-chrome finish and stunning color shifts make this polish a standout in any collection. Experience the enchantment of Jay Ryan Cosmetics and discover the endless possibilities of holographic nail polishes.

Exploring Splattered Paint Lacquer

Splattered Paint Lacquer offers unique and textured finishes that add depth and dimension to your manicures. "Spring Thaw" features a darker gray jelly base adorned with various sizes of silver holographic and matte gray glitters. While the chunky texture may pose a challenge during removal, the end result is a stunning and eye-catching manicure that stands out from the crowd.

Mrs Smith's Multi-Chrome Magic

Mrs Smith's offers multi-chrome magic with their range of stunning nail polishes. "Lulu" showcases a bronze ultra-chrome base with gold flakes and a mesmerizing multi-chrome shift. Each polish from Mrs Smith's guarantees a unique and eye-catching manicure that will leave you in awe. Illuminate your nails with the captivating magic of Mrs Smith's multi-chrome nail polishes.

Glitter by Erica: A Dark and Mysterious Choice

If you're drawn to dark and mysterious shades, Glitter by Erica is the brand for you. "Watcher on the Wall" presents a black jelly base filled with silver hexes, light blue hexes, and silver circles. While the circular glitters may require a bit of extra effort to distribute evenly, the end result is a manicure that commands attention. Embrace the dark side with Glitter by Erica and indulge in the enigmatic allure of their unique nail polishes.


Indulging in a nail polish haul on Etsy is an exciting adventure that allows you to support independent brands and discover hidden gems. From nostalgic circular glitters to shifty and mesmerizing multi-chrome finishes, the world of indie nail polishes on Etsy has something to offer every nail polish enthusiast. So dive in, explore, and let your nails become a canvas for creativity and self-expression.


  • Explore the vibrant world of indie nail polishes on Etsy.
  • Discover unique brands like Whimsical Ideas by Pam and Frankenstein and Heel Polishes.
  • Embrace the unconventional bottles of Comet Vomit and the elegant packaging of Black Dahlia Lacquer.
  • Delve into the ethereal shades of Pop Nail Polish and the shifty delights of Jay Ryan Cosmetics.
  • Experience textured finishes from Splattered Paint Lacquer and multi-chrome magic from Mrs Smith's.
  • Channel your dark side with Glitter by Erica's mysterious nail polishes.


1. Are these nail polishes cruelty-free? Most indie nail polish brands on Etsy prioritize ethical practices and offer cruelty-free options. However, it is always recommended to check the individual seller's policies for detailed information.

2. How long do these nail polishes last on the nails? The longevity of nail polishes can vary depending on factors such as application technique, top coat usage, and individual nail health. Generally, well-applied indie polishes have good staying power and can last up to a week or more.

3. Can these nail polishes be used with gel or acrylic nails? Many indie nail polishes are suitable for use with gel or acrylic nails. However, it is best to check with the seller or read the product descriptions for specific instructions or recommendations.

4. Are these nail polishes easy to remove? Textured and glitter-heavy nail polishes can require extra effort to remove compared to regular polishes. It is advisable to use a proper nail polish remover and follow the appropriate removal techniques for the best results.

5. How can I support indie nail polish brands on Etsy? Supporting indie brands on Etsy is as simple as making a purchase from their shop. By choosing to buy from independent sellers, you contribute directly to their growth and success in the industry. Additionally, leaving positive reviews and spreading the word about your favorite brands can also greatly support them.

I am a ETSY merchant, I am opening several ETSY stores. I use Etsyshop to find ETSY stores and track competitor stores. Etsyshop really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to Etsyshop's service, I hope more people can like Etsyshop! — Ecomvy

Join Etsyshop to find the ETSY store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
ETSY Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial
Browse More Content