The Dark Truth of Selling on Etsy

The Dark Truth of Selling on Etsy

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. The Ugly Side of Selling on Etsy
    1. The Stress of Running an Etsy Shop
    2. Breaking Etsy Rules
    3. Difficulty in Making Certain Products
    4. Time-Consuming Process of Growing Your Shop
    5. More Sales, Less Creativity
    6. Some Products Don't Sell
  3. Is Selling on Etsy Worth It?
  4. Conclusion

Selling on Etsy: The Ugly Truths Revealed


Selling on Etsy can be an exciting and lucrative venture, but it's not without its challenges. While many people highlight the positive aspects of running an Etsy shop, there are certain ugly truths that sellers often keep hidden. In this article, we're going to shed light on the less glamorous side of selling on Etsy and discuss the hurdles that sellers face. So, if you're considering starting an Etsy shop or already have one, buckle up and prepare for some real talk.

The Ugly Side of Selling on Etsy

1. The Stress of Running an Etsy Shop

Starting an Etsy shop may seem simple, but once you dive into the world of running a business, things can quickly become overwhelming. While setting up your shop is relatively easy, the stress arises when it comes to maintaining and growing your business. Etsy has its own set of rules that sellers must adhere to, and breaking any of these rules can have severe consequences, including the potential suspension of your entire shop. This can be particularly nerve-wracking if Etsy is your sole selling platform. Even unintentionally violating a rule, as I experienced with a listing featuring designer goods in the background, can lead to your listing being taken down. Dealing with Etsy support can be a nightmare, amplifying the stress levels even further.

2. Breaking Etsy Rules

Etsy's marketplace operates under a strict set of rules, and it's crucial for sellers to fully understand and comply with them. However, even with the best intentions, it's surprisingly easy to unintentionally break these rules. In my case, I unknowingly violated an Etsy rule when attempting to refresh a listing for joggers. The listing had been active for a year, and I decided to update it with new pictures. Little did I know that the background of the images showcased designer goods. As a result, my listing was swiftly deactivated. This incident taught me the importance of thoroughly reviewing my product photos and ensuring they don't inadvertently include any prohibited items. The ordeal was stressful, as my entire shop could have been jeopardized.

3. Difficulty in Making Certain Products

Another harsh truth of selling on Etsy is that some products simply aren't worth the effort. While you may create beautiful items that attract buyers, factors such as production time and cost-effectiveness play significant roles. Certain products may require too many resources or take too long to make, making them challenging to turn a profit on. I experienced this firsthand with a custom birthday t-shirt. Although the shirt sold well and generated a good profit, the process of producing it was arduous and undesirable. It involved multiple pressings, intricate vinyl cuttings, and a high potential for errors. Eventually, my fiancé and I decided to discontinue the shirt, despite its profitability, as the process was overwhelming and made us despise a part of our business.

4. Time-Consuming Process of Growing Your Shop

While setting up an Etsy shop may be relatively quick, turning it into a successful venture that generates consistent sales and significant revenue is a time-consuming task. Whether you're selling physical or digital products, building your shop's inventory and optimizing your listings require substantial time investments. Adding more listings to your shop not only improves its visibility but also enhances your chances of making sales. However, creating aesthetically pleasing listings with captivating photos, thorough product descriptions, and engaging information takes time. Additionally, if you sell physical products, you need to focus on providing excellent customer service, refreshing your listings regularly, and enhancing your packaging to create a memorable experience for buyers. All these tasks demand attention and contribute to the overall time commitment of managing an Etsy shop.

5. More Sales, Less Creativity

One of the enjoyable aspects of starting an Etsy shop is the opportunity for creativity and personalization. However, as your shop grows and you start making more sales, the demands of quantity and efficiency can sometimes hinder your creativity. What once seemed like a collaborative and creatively fulfilling process may eventually turn into a streamlined operation with limited room for customization. This is especially true for sellers of standardized products, where production efficiency becomes a priority. The more you strive for scaling and optimization, the less time and flexibility you have to engage with customers on a personal level or experiment with new designs. It's a delicate balance to maintain both creativity and efficiency as your shop expands.

6. Some Products Don't Sell

While it's disheartening to accept, the reality is that some products simply won't sell, regardless of your efforts. Even if you conduct thorough research, create compelling listings, and target the right audience, sales may not materialize. This can be frustrating, especially when you see other items in your shop performing well. It's essential to continue experimenting, tweaking listings, and staying proactive. Not every product will resonate with buyers, but through trial and error, you'll learn valuable lessons and discover what works best for your Etsy shop.

Is Selling on Etsy Worth It?

After understanding the challenges and ugly truths of selling on Etsy, you might be questioning whether it's worth the effort. Despite the stress and hurdles, I can confidently say that selling on Etsy is indeed worth it. As someone who has been selling on Etsy for two years, I can attest to the potential for substantial revenue and growth. Currently, my monthly revenue ranges between $10,000 and $15,000, which is a promising start. However, it's important to differentiate between revenue and profit when evaluating success on Etsy. Nevertheless, the potential for growth and the opportunity to build a thriving business are undoubtedly present on the platform. So, if you're willing to put in the hard work, overcome the challenges, and continuously evolve, selling on Etsy can be a fulfilling and rewarding venture.


Selling on Etsy can be a rollercoaster ride that encompasses both triumphs and challenges. Understanding the less glamorous aspects, such as the stress of managing your shop, the risks of breaking Etsy rules, the difficulties in making certain products, the time-consuming process of growing your shop, the potential loss of creativity with increased sales, and the occasional failure of certain products, is crucial for establishing realistic expectations. Despite these hardships, the potential for success, growth, and financial gain makes selling on Etsy a worthwhile pursuit for many entrepreneurs. So, if you're up for the challenge and armed with perseverance, creativity, and a dedication to your craft, launching and nurturing an Etsy shop can be a rewarding journey filled with opportunities for personal and professional growth.


  • Selling on Etsy comes with its fair share of challenges and hardships, which sellers often keep hidden.
  • Breaking Etsy rules can have severe consequences, and even unintentionally violating them can jeopardize your entire shop.
  • Some products may be difficult or costly to create, making it challenging to achieve profitability.
  • Growing and maintaining an Etsy shop requires a significant time investment, from optimizing listings to providing excellent customer service.
  • More sales often lead to less creativity, as the focus shifts towards streamlining operations and meeting demand.
  • Despite the challenges, selling on Etsy is worth it, with the potential for significant revenue and personal growth.


Q: Can I sell multiple products on Etsy? A: Absolutely! Etsy allows sellers to offer a wide range of products, from handmade crafts to vintage items and digital downloads.

Q: How much time should I expect to invest in managing my Etsy shop? A: The amount of time required varies depending on the scale of your shop and the products you sell. Expect to spend several hours each week optimizing listings, fulfilling orders, and providing customer support.

Q: What should I do if my listings aren't selling? A: If your listings aren't generating sales, consider conducting market research, optimizing your listings with relevant keywords, improving product photos, and experimenting with different pricing strategies.

Q: Is it possible to run an Etsy shop alongside another job or commitment? A: Yes, many sellers manage their Etsy shops while juggling other responsibilities. However, it's important to find a balance that allows you to dedicate enough time and effort to your shop's needs.

Q: Is it necessary to offer free shipping on Etsy? A: While offering free shipping can be enticing to buyers, it's not mandatory. It's a business decision that you should evaluate based on your product's pricing, profit margins, and competition.

I am a ETSY merchant, I am opening several ETSY stores. I use Etsyshop to find ETSY stores and track competitor stores. Etsyshop really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to Etsyshop's service, I hope more people can like Etsyshop! — Ecomvy

Join Etsyshop to find the ETSY store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
ETSY Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial
Browse More Content