Pros & Cons of Selling on Etsy

Pros & Cons of Selling on Etsy

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. The Pros of Selling on Etsy in 2022
    1. Tremendous Growth and Increased Shoppers
    2. Etsy's Trustworthiness and Established Reputation
    3. Availability of Tools for Etsy Sellers
    4. Advertising Opportunities on the Platform
  3. The Cons of Selling on Etsy in 2022
    1. Rising Competition and Market Saturation
    2. Lack of Ownership and Control Over Your Shop
    3. Increased Transaction Fees
    4. Challenges in Building Brand Recognition
  4. How to Navigate the Challenges and Succeed on Etsy
    1. Tips for Standing Out in a Saturated Market
    2. Ensuring Compliance with Etsy Policies
    3. Strategies for Branding and Building Recognition
    4. Managing Finances and Pricing Effectively
  5. Conclusion
  6. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Pros and Cons of Selling on Etsy in 2022

Etsy, the popular online marketplace, has witnessed significant growth in recent years, reaching a staggering 96.3 million shoppers in 2021. This remarkable expansion provides sellers with a vast customer base and increased sales opportunities. Moreover, Etsy's credibility and trustworthiness among customers are paramount, fostering a loyal following. The platform's emphasis on quality and professionalism ensures that buyers can shop with confidence, enhancing the overall shopping experience. Additionally, Etsy offers a range of tools and resources, simplifying the journey for aspiring entrepreneurs. From logo creation to website development, sellers can establish their brands with ease. Furthermore, Etsy's advertising platform allows sellers to target a warm audience directly, boosting product visibility.

Navigating Challenges and Thriving on Etsy

Rising Competition and Market Saturation: While Etsy's growth is advantageous, the surge in the number of shops intensifies competition. Standing out amidst a saturated market demands professionalism and high-quality products. Top sellers on Etsy invest in top-notch photography and presentation, ensuring their products outshine the competition. By understanding the platform's best practices and studying successful listings, sellers can enhance their visibility and sales.

Lack of Ownership and Control Over Your Shop: A critical consideration for sellers on Etsy is the lack of control over the platform. Unlike operating an independent website, Etsy sellers are subject to the platform's policies and decisions. Although Etsy seldom closes shops without reason, adhering to their guidelines and policies is vital. Sellers must familiarize themselves with Etsy's regulations to avoid potential issues and ensure a smooth business journey.

Increased Transaction Fees: Etsy's decision to raise transaction fees to 6.5% is a financial consideration for sellers. While higher fees are never ideal, they are a part of the cost of doing business on any online marketplace. Sellers need to incorporate these fees into their pricing strategies, ensuring their products remain competitive while covering expenses.

Challenges in Building Brand Recognition: Establishing a unique brand identity on Etsy can be challenging, given the platform's prominence. However, strategic branding efforts can help sellers overcome this hurdle. Consistent use of logos, brand names, and messaging across packaging, social media, and communication channels fosters recognition. Personalizing interactions with customers and crafting compelling narratives about the brand can also aid in building a loyal customer base.


In conclusion, selling on Etsy offers immense opportunities for entrepreneurs, but it's not without its challenges. By leveraging the platform's strengths, navigating its limitations, and implementing effective strategies, sellers can build successful businesses on Etsy. Understanding the market, investing in quality, and embracing creative branding are key to thriving in this competitive marketplace.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1: Is it still profitable to sell on Etsy given the rising competition? A1: Yes, Etsy can be highly profitable, even with increased competition. Success lies in offering unique products, exceptional quality, and strategic marketing. Standing out through professionalism and creativity is crucial.

Q2: How can I protect my shop from potential closures on Etsy? A2: Ensuring compliance with Etsy's policies is paramount. Regularly review their guidelines, respond promptly to customer inquiries, ship orders on time, and maintain excellent customer service. Proactive adherence to rules minimizes the risk of closure.

Q3: What are some effective strategies for building brand recognition on Etsy? A3: Consistency is key. Use your brand name and logo on all materials, including packaging and social media. Craft a compelling brand story, engage customers personally, and create memorable experiences. Building a unique and recognizable brand identity fosters customer loyalty.

Q4: How can I price my products competitively while covering Etsy's transaction fees? A4: Calculate your production costs, including materials, labor, and overheads. Factor in Etsy's transaction fees when determining the retail price. Consider offering value-added services or bundled products to enhance perceived value without significantly increasing costs.

Q5: What are the advantages of utilizing Etsy ads compared to other advertising platforms? A5: Etsy ads allow you to target an audience already interested in similar products, maximizing the likelihood of conversions. Detailed analytics enable you to assess the ad's effectiveness and make data-driven decisions, optimizing your advertising budget for better results.

I am a ETSY merchant, I am opening several ETSY stores. I use Etsyshop to find ETSY stores and track competitor stores. Etsyshop really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to Etsyshop's service, I hope more people can like Etsyshop! — Ecomvy

Join Etsyshop to find the ETSY store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
ETSY Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial
Browse More Content