Etsy's Changing Landscape: Key Insights

Etsy's Changing Landscape: Key Insights

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction
  2. The Changing Landscape of Etsy
  3. The Evolving Definition of "Handmade"
  4. The Pros and Cons of the Increasing Number of Sellers
  5. The Challenges of Launching Collections
  6. The Impact of SEO on Etsy Shops
  7. The Importance of Balancing SEO with Human-Friendly Content
  8. The Shift in Etsy's Search Algorithm
  9. The Influence of Buyer Behavior on Search Results
  10. The Need for Adaptability in Etsy Selling Strategies

The Changing Landscape of Etsy

Etsy, the popular online marketplace for handmade and vintage goods, has undergone significant changes in recent years. As a long-time seller on the platform, I reopened my shop after a year-long hiatus and was surprised by the transformations that had taken place. In this article, I will share three key things that I have learned since reopening my Etsy shop a year ago, shedding light on the evolving nature of the marketplace and the challenges it presents for sellers.

Introduction: A Year of Rediscovery

Before delving into the specifics, let me provide a brief introduction. I initially started my Etsy shop back in 2007, and I had been running it as a business for the past nine years. However, due to the unforeseen circumstances brought about by the COVID-19 pandemic, I made the difficult decision to close my shop temporarily in March 2020. Little did I know that this temporary closure would last over a year, and reopening my shop in July 2021 came with its own set of surprises. In the paragraphs that follow, I will reflect on the lessons learned during this period and discuss the changes that have taken place within the Etsy ecosystem.

The Changing Landscape of Etsy Over the past year, the Etsy marketplace has experienced exponential growth in terms of the number of sellers. In 2019, there were approximately 2.6 million sellers on the platform, and by the end of 2021, that number had skyrocketed to seven and a half million. With such a substantial increase in sellers, one might assume that the marketplace has become oversaturated. However, it is crucial to consider the flip side of this situation. The influx of sellers has also attracted a larger customer base, resulting in increased buyer activity. Therefore, while the competition has undoubtedly intensified, so has the potential customer reach.

The Evolving Definition of "Handmade" When it comes to Etsy, one would expect the focus to be on genuinely handmade items. However, the past year has witnessed a notable shift in this aspect. While Etsy explicitly prohibits reselling on its platform, the reality is that the handmade category has become inundated with sellers reselling mass-produced items, masquerading them as handmade. This trend has significantly eroded the distinction between Etsy and other e-commerce giants like eBay or Amazon. While the inclusion of resold items may not necessarily be an inherent problem, it dilutes the essence of Etsy as a marketplace for genuinely unique handmade goods. Sellers should adhere to the core principles of the platform and maintain the integrity of the handmade category.

The Pros and Cons of the Increasing Number of Sellers The surge in the number of sellers on Etsy brings both advantages and disadvantages. On the positive side, the higher volume of sellers indicates a thriving marketplace with a vast array of products for buyers to explore. This increased competition can also inspire sellers to innovate and offer unique items to stand out from the crowd. However, the flip side is that standing out in a sea of sellers becomes increasingly challenging. Differentiating oneself and attracting customers' attention requires careful strategy, branding, and exceptional product quality.

The Challenges of Launching Collections As a seller, one strategy I experimented with upon reopening my shop was launching collections instead of drip-feeding individual items. This approach proved effective in generating excitement among customers and maintaining their interest. However, it came with its fair share of challenges. Staying organized and adhering to the timeline for releasing items within a collection proved to be more difficult than anticipated. Despite my efforts, I often found myself struggling with delays, which affected the overall flow of inventory in my shop. Additionally, my SEO performance suffered as I had less time to devote to keyword research for each individual listing within a collection.

The Impact of SEO on Etsy Shops SEO (Search Engine Optimization) plays a vital role in the discoverability of Etsy shops. However, what worked in terms of SEO strategies before my shop closure in 2020 no longer yielded the same results upon reopening. Etsy's search algorithm has evolved, giving more weightage to factors like buyer behavior and history. Consequently, sellers have less control over where their items rank in search results. Balancing the optimization of listings for SEO while also providing compelling and human-friendly descriptions has become more crucial than ever.

The Importance of Balancing SEO with Human-Friendly Content Crafting effective SEO-optimized listings on Etsy now requires striking a delicate balance. While keywords are still relevant, sellers must create product descriptions and content that resonate with potential customers on a human level. No longer can sellers simply stuff their listings with keywords. Instead, they must provide detailed and engaging descriptions that captivate buyers. Finding this balance and creating high-quality content can be a challenge, but it is essential for gaining visibility and attracting the right audience.

The Shift in Etsy's Search Algorithm Etsy's search algorithm has transformed significantly in recent years. Formerly, sellers had more control over where their items would appear in search results. However, the current algorithm takes into account not only the seller's shop optimization but also the buyer's behavior. This dual focus has added an extra layer of complexity to the search landscape on Etsy. Sellers must adapt their strategies accordingly and consider both sides of the equation when optimizing their listings.

The Influence of Buyer Behavior on Search Results Buyer behavior plays a significant role in Etsy's search results. The algorithm now considers factors such as past purchase history, preferences, and interactions to deliver personalized search results. This means that even if a seller has meticulously optimized their listings, they may not appear in front of certain buyers if they do not align with their preferences. Understanding and adapting to this dynamic is crucial for sellers looking to maximize their visibility and reach on Etsy.

The Need for Adaptability in Etsy Selling Strategies Navigating the ever-changing landscape of Etsy requires sellers to be adaptable and open to new approaches. Regularly assessing and fine-tuning selling strategies is essential to stay ahead in the competitive marketplace. Embracing flexibility and being willing to experiment with different techniques will enable sellers to adjust to the evolving dynamics of Etsy and better meet the needs and expectations of their customers.


Q: Is it still possible to succeed on Etsy with the increasing number of sellers? A: Yes, it is still possible to succeed on Etsy despite the growing competition. Success lies in differentiating oneself through unique products, exceptional quality, effective branding, and strategic marketing efforts.

Q: How can sellers optimize their listings for both SEO and human-friendliness? A: Sellers should strive to strike a balance between SEO optimization and creating engaging, human-friendly content. This entails thorough keyword research, crafting informative and captivating descriptions, and ensuring that the content resonates with potential customers on an emotional level.

Q: What should sellers consider when launching collections on Etsy? A: Launching collections can create excitement among customers. However, sellers should carefully plan and stay organized to ensure timely releases and maintain inventory consistency. Additionally, attention should be given to maintaining SEO quality for individual listings within a collection.

Q: How has the Etsy search algorithm changed over time? A: The Etsy search algorithm has evolved to consider not only the seller's optimization but also the buyer's behavior and preferences. Sellers must adapt their strategies to find the right balance between optimizing their listings and catering to the personalized search experiences of buyers.

I am a ETSY merchant, I am opening several ETSY stores. I use Etsyshop to find ETSY stores and track competitor stores. Etsyshop really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to Etsyshop's service, I hope more people can like Etsyshop! — Ecomvy

Join Etsyshop to find the ETSY store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
ETSY Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial
Browse More Content