Etsy vs Shopify: Unveiling the Truth

Etsy vs Shopify: Unveiling the Truth

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction to Etsy and Other Platforms
  2. The Reality of Etsy Fees
  3. Running Your Own Platform vs Etsy 3.1 Setting Up Your Own Website 3.2 Building a Social Media Presence 3.3 Driving Traffic to Your Website
  4. The Reality of Competition on Etsy 4.1 Standing Out from the Crowd 4.2 Researching Trends and Demographics 4.3 Tailoring Unique Designs
  5. The Best Approach for New Sellers 5.1 Starting with Etsy 5.2 Validating Products and Designs 5.3 Transitioning to Your Own Platform
  6. Conclusion

Is Etsy the Right Platform for Your Business?

Considering all the chatter on social media about Etsy and its competitors, it's natural to wonder if Etsy is the right platform for your business. As someone who has built successful six-figure businesses on both Etsy and other platforms, I can provide some context and insights into this debate. In this article, we will explore the reality of Etsy fees, the advantages and challenges of running your own platform, the competition on Etsy, and the best approach for new sellers. By the end, you'll have a clearer understanding of whether or not Etsy is the right fit for your business.

The Reality of Etsy Fees

One common argument against using Etsy is the perception that its fees eat into sellers' profits. While Etsy does have fees, it's essential to consider them in context. Many sellers on Etsy and other platforms often underprice their products or fail to understand their costs, resulting in minimal profits. To set a fair price for your products, it's crucial to calculate your costs accurately, including materials, time, and any applicable platform fees. Etsy fees are relatively low compared to other platforms, making it a cost-effective choice for many sellers. Understanding your costs and pricing your products accordingly is a fundamental aspect of running a successful business.

Running Your Own Platform vs Etsy

One significant consideration when deciding on a platform is whether to run your own website or use an existing marketplace like Etsy. Each option has its pros and cons. Etsy provides a readily available platform that brings in millions of potential customers. It also allows you to experiment with different products and designs, helping you validate your business and identify what works. On the other hand, starting your own platform requires more effort and technical know-how, but it provides greater control and brand autonomy. It's vital to carefully evaluate your needs, resources, and goals before making this decision.

  1. Setting Up Your Own Website Setting up your own website using platforms like Shopify or Wix offers more control but also requires more technical knowledge. You would need to configure your website from top to bottom, set up payment processing, design a cohesive website, and optimize it for search engine visibility. While this option provides more flexibility, it also requires more time and investment.

  2. Building a Social Media Presence Regardless of the platform you choose, building a social media presence is crucial for driving traffic and building a brand. However, starting from scratch with your own platform means you'll also need to invest in building a social media following. It will take time and effort to attract and engage potential customers.

  3. Driving Traffic to Your Website One common challenge with running your own platform is driving traffic. Unlike Etsy, which already has a vast number of shoppers, attracting customers to your website requires additional marketing efforts. You may need to invest in advertising, build an email list, or use social media and search engine optimization strategies to gain visibility.

The Reality of Competition on Etsy

Another concern for many sellers is the level of competition on Etsy. With millions of sellers on the platform, it's important to stand out from the crowd. Generic designs or low-quality listings are unlikely to succeed. Research and understanding your target audience are crucial for identifying trends, designing unique products, and building a niche within Etsy's marketplace. By focusing on specific customers and creating products that resonate with them, you can carve out a profitable space despite the competition.

  1. Standing Out from the Crowd Differentiating yourself from other sellers is vital for success on Etsy. Your designs should be high-quality, unique, and tailored to your target audience. Avoid copying existing listings or competing solely on price. Instead, invest time in creating designs that stand out and attract customers.

  2. Researching Trends and Demographics Research plays a crucial role in identifying trends and understanding your target audience. Utilize tools like eRank or Everbe to find products in demand from less established sellers. You can also look at retailers or do trend research on platforms like Pinterest. By identifying customer demographics and niche markets, you can create products that meet their specific needs.

  3. Tailoring Unique Designs Building a successful business on Etsy relies on offering something unique. Avoid generic designs and invest time in creating products that stand out. By understanding your target audience and their preferences, you can tailor your designs to meet their specific demands. This approach opens doors to success on Etsy and helps you compete effectively.

The Best Approach for New Sellers

For new sellers without an existing following, starting with Etsy is often the best approach. It provides a platform to experiment with products, validate ideas, and connect with millions of potential customers. By mastering the Etsy marketplace and building a reputation, you can gain valuable insights into what sells and develop a strong foundation for your business. Once you have traction and want to expand further, you can consider exploring other platforms or setting up your own website.

  1. Starting with Etsy Etsy offers a low barrier to entry and a platform with built-in traffic. It allows new sellers to discover what products and designs resonate with their audience. Starting on Etsy provides an opportunity to learn, pivot, and refine your business while gaining exposure to millions of shoppers.

  2. Validating Products and Designs The early stages on Etsy allow you to validate your products and designs. By closely monitoring sales and customer response, you can fine-tune your offerings and target a profitable niche. Use this time to gather data and insights that will inform your business decisions moving forward.

  3. Transitioning to Your Own Platform Once you have a clearer understanding of your target audience, the viability of your products, and the demand for your brand, you can consider expanding beyond Etsy. This may involve setting up your own website on platforms like Shopify, Wix, or Squarespace. By funneling your Etsy customers to your own platform while still benefiting from Etsy's organic traffic, you can gradually transition to greater brand autonomy.


In the ever-evolving world of e-commerce, choosing the right platform is crucial for your business's success. While Etsy may not be perfect, it offers numerous advantages, such as built-in traffic, low fees compared to other platforms, and the opportunity to experiment and validate your products. By understanding the reality of Etsy fees, the challenges and benefits of running your own platform, and the strategies for standing out amidst competition, you can make an informed decision for your business. Remember, success is not determined by the platform alone but by your dedication, creativity, and ability to adapt in a dynamic marketplace.

I am a ETSY merchant, I am opening several ETSY stores. I use Etsyshop to find ETSY stores and track competitor stores. Etsyshop really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to Etsyshop's service, I hope more people can like Etsyshop! — Ecomvy

Join Etsyshop to find the ETSY store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
ETSY Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial
Browse More Content