Boosting Sales: Etsy vs. Personal Website

Boosting Sales: Etsy vs. Personal Website

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. The Role of a Website alongside Etsy
  3. Comparison of Sales and Traffic
    • 3.1. Etsy vs. Website Sales
    • 3.2. The Importance of Quality Visits
  4. The Etsy Algorithm and Organic Traffic
    • 4.1. Understanding Etsy's Algorithm
    • 4.2. Strategies for Generating Traffic
  5. Building a Strong Community
    • 5.1. The Significance of a Community
    • 5.2. Creating and Nurturing a Mailing List
  6. Transitioning to a Website
  7. Website Building and Promotion
  8. Long-Term Growth and Success
  9. Challenges and Considerations
  10. Conclusion

The Role of a Website alongside Etsy

In today's digital age, many artisans and crafters are turning to e-commerce to reach a wider audience and boost their sales. Setting up a website alongside your Etsy shop can be a strategic move to expand your online presence. In this article, we'll explore the benefits and challenges of running a website in conjunction with an Etsy shop.


Recently, I set up a website not to replace my Etsy shop but to work alongside it, and I have been pouring my energy into this new endeavor. Many people have been curious about how my website's sales and traffic compare to Etsy, and I've decided to delve into this topic more deeply. While I plan to provide a behind-the-scenes look at my website's performance in the future, I'd like to address the comparison between Etsy and a personal website. It's crucial to dispel the notion that a website is a quick fix for increasing traffic and sales. In my experience, the difference between the two platforms is minimal. However, there's a fundamental reason for this, which I discussed in a previous video, linked here for your reference.

Comparison of Sales and Traffic

Etsy vs. Website Sales

When it comes to comparing sales on Etsy and a personal website, my experience has been intriguing. While I've been getting fewer visits to my website, I'm making roughly the same number of sales as I did on Etsy. This brings us to a critical point – the number of visits or views your shop receives is not as important as conversion rates.

The Importance of Quality Visits

When considering your shop's performance, it's vital to focus on attracting the right kind of visitors: those who genuinely intend to make a purchase. SEO and generating views are crucial, but equally significant is the ability to convert those views into actual sales.

The Etsy Algorithm and Organic Traffic

Understanding Etsy's Algorithm

Etsy relies on algorithms to promote shops, but it's essential to understand how these algorithms work. While Etsy should theoretically pick up on your efforts to drive traffic to your shop, it doesn't always happen this way.

Strategies for Generating Traffic

I've employed an approach where I assumed all marketing and promotion were my responsibility, both on and off Etsy. By doing so, I ensured that I was the primary driver of traffic to my shop, and this concept remains the same for my website. This might not work for everyone, but it suits my business model.

Building a Strong Community

The Significance of a Community

I believe that building a community around your business is fundamental to its growth. A loyal customer base can significantly impact your sales and success.

Creating and Nurturing a Mailing List

Another vital aspect is maintaining a mailing list. Even in this age of social media, a mailing list is a powerful tool that you can carry with you across various online platforms. It's not about collecting numbers but attracting individuals genuinely interested in your work.

Transitioning to a Website

Shifting from Etsy to a personal website can be a significant step. It's essential to evaluate your readiness and budget before making this transition.

Website Building and Promotion

Creating a website takes time and effort, but it's a worthy investment. Success is not guaranteed overnight, but with dedication, you can see results.

Long-Term Growth and Success

I've witnessed consistent sales and traffic after transitioning to a website. However, it's vital to remember that success requires time, effort, and a focus on building a strong community.

Challenges and Considerations

Running a website alongside an Etsy shop comes with its unique set of challenges and considerations. It's not a one-size-fits-all solution, and your approach should align with your business goals and resources.


In conclusion, a website can complement your Etsy shop, but it's not a quick fix. Success is built on a strong community, a well-nurtured mailing list, and the ability to attract quality visitors who convert into buyers. If you're considering making the transition to a personal website, ensure that you're well-prepared for the journey ahead.


  • Comparing sales and traffic between Etsy and a personal website.
  • The importance of quality visits over sheer numbers.
  • Understanding Etsy's algorithm and the role it plays.
  • Building a strong community and nurturing a mailing list.
  • Considerations and challenges when transitioning to a website.


Q1: What are the key differences between sales on Etsy and a personal website? A1: Sales on Etsy and a personal website may not differ significantly. It's crucial to focus on converting visitors into buyers.

Q2: How does the Etsy algorithm impact shop performance? A2: Etsy's algorithm is vital, but it doesn't always function as expected. Understanding its nuances is essential for success.

Q3: What role does building a community and a mailing list play in e-commerce? A3: Building a community and maintaining a mailing list are essential for long-term success, as they provide a loyal customer base.

Q4: What challenges should one consider when transitioning to a personal website? A4: Shifting to a website comes with unique challenges, and readiness and budget should be evaluated before making the transition.

I am a ETSY merchant, I am opening several ETSY stores. I use Etsyshop to find ETSY stores and track competitor stores. Etsyshop really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to Etsyshop's service, I hope more people can like Etsyshop! — Ecomvy

Join Etsyshop to find the ETSY store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
ETSY Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial
Browse More Content