Avoid These Mistakes When Copying Etsy Tags and Titles

Avoid These Mistakes When Copying Etsy Tags and Titles

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction
  2. The Temptation to Copy Competitors
  3. Why Copying Tags and Titles Doesn't Work
  4. Etsy's Personalized Search Algorithm
  5. Etsy's Goal of Making Sales
  6. Etsy's Preference for Variety
  7. Keyword Credibility and Building Trust
  8. The Influence of Non-SEO Traffic
  9. Seasonality and its Impact on Keywords
  10. Alternative Strategies for Keyword Research

The Perils of Copying Competitors' Tags and Titles


In the fast-paced world of online selling, it's natural to look for shortcuts to success. One of the most tempting shortcuts is to copy the tags and titles from a successful competitor's listing. After all, if they are showing up at the top of search results, they must be doing something right, right? Well, not quite. In this article, we'll delve into this "copy and paste" approach and explore why it's a terrible idea. We'll explain why Etsy's personalized search algorithm, keyword credibility, non-SEO traffic, and seasonality all play a significant role in the success of your listings. By the end of this article, you'll understand why it's crucial to approach keyword research with a fresh perspective and use alternative strategies to optimize your listings effectively.

The Temptation to Copy Competitors:

In the competitive world of e-commerce, it's only natural to try to replicate the success of top sellers. When you stumble upon an Etsy listing that is performing exceptionally well, it's tempting to assume that copying its tags and title will lead to similar results. After all, if they've already done the hard work of finding the right keywords, why reinvent the wheel? However, succumbing to this temptation can be a grave mistake. While it may save you time initially, it can cost you dearly in the long run. Let's explore why.

Why Copying Tags and Titles Doesn't Work:

Etsy's Personalized Search Algorithm:

Etsy employs a personalized search algorithm that aims to show customers products they are most likely to buy. The algorithm takes into account various factors, including relevance to the search query, item quality, and the buyer's purchase history. This means that the top-ranking listings you see may not necessarily be the best performers for a given keyword. Etsy's goal is to land a sale, not just show the most popular listings. By assuming that the top-ranked listings represent the best keywords, you're already starting off on the wrong foot.

Etsy's Preference for Variety:

Etsy is all about providing a unique and boutique experience to its customers. It doesn't aim to showcase only the top sellers or the most popular items. Instead, Etsy wants to offer variety and cater to different tastes and preferences. This means that even if a listing is performing exceptionally well for a particular keyword, it doesn't guarantee the same success for other keywords. By blindly copying a listing's tags and assuming they will work for you, you're disregarding the crucial element of variety that Etsy values.

Keyword Credibility and Building Trust:

One critical aspect of Etsy's search algorithm is keyword credibility. Over time, Etsy learns how well listings perform for specific keywords based on user interactions such as clicks and purchases. Listings that receive a high engagement rate for a particular keyword gain credibility in the eyes of the algorithm. When you copy a competitor's tags and titles, you may be overlooking the fact that they have built up the credibility for those keywords over time. Without a similar track record, it's unlikely that you will see the same level of success.

The Influence of Non-SEO Traffic:

While SEO is essential for gaining visibility on Etsy, it's not the only factor that drives traffic and sales. Many successful sellers utilize non-SEO sources such as ads, social media, mailing lists, and promotions to attract customers to their listings. When you're copying a competitor's tags and titles, you're not privy to the strategies they use outside of Etsy's SEO framework. Their success might be attributed to these non-SEO sources rather than their keyword optimization alone. It's crucial to consider the bigger picture and not rely solely on SEO when trying to replicate success.

Seasonality and its Impact on Keywords:

Seasonality is a critical factor to consider in keyword research. Shopping trends vary throughout the year, and what worked well for a keyword in one season may not necessarily yield the same results in another. Copying a competitor's keywords without considering the seasonality factor can lead to disappointment and low sales. It's important to stay updated on current trends and conduct thorough research to identify keywords that align with the current season and market demand.

Alternative Strategies for Keyword Research:

Copying tags and titles may seem like a convenient shortcut, but it often leads to mediocre results. Instead of blindly imitating your competitors, consider alternative strategies for keyword research that will help you stand out and attract your target audience. Tools like Marmalead can provide valuable insights into the performance of keywords and help you make informed decisions. Testing and measuring the success of your chosen keywords is vital, as it allows you to refine your strategy over time and continually optimize your listings for maximum visibility and sales.


While it's tempting to copy the tags and titles of successful competitors, this approach is unlikely to yield the desired results. Etsy's personalized search algorithm, the importance of keyword credibility, non-SEO traffic sources, and seasonality all play significant roles in the success of your listings. By utilizing alternative strategies for keyword research, such as using tools like Marmalead and considering non-SEO factors, you can optimize your listings effectively and increase your chances of success on Etsy. Remember, it's important to approach keyword research with a fresh perspective and adapt your strategies based on continuous testing and measurement.

I am a ETSY merchant, I am opening several ETSY stores. I use Etsyshop to find ETSY stores and track competitor stores. Etsyshop really helped me a lot, I also subscribe to Etsyshop's service, I hope more people can like Etsyshop! — Ecomvy

Join Etsyshop to find the ETSY store & products

To make it happen in 3 seconds.

Sign Up
App rating
ETSY Store
Trusted Customers
No complicated
No difficulty
Free trial
Browse More Content