The Truth About Selling Handmade on Etsy - Is it Worth It?

The Truth About Selling Handmade on Etsy - Is it Worth It?

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. The Complicated Relationship with Etsy
  3. Using Etsy as a Sales Tool
  4. Low Investment Fees
  5. The Competitive Nature of Etsy
  6. Etsy as the Best Fit for Your Business
  7. Emotional Connection to Etsy
  8. Metrics to Consider
  9. Conclusion
  10. FAQ

Is Selling on Etsy Worth it?

Etsy has become a popular platform for selling handmade goods, but many sellers find themselves questioning if it is truly worth it. In this article, we will explore the various reasons why sellers continue to use Etsy despite its challenges and limitations. We will discuss the different aspects of Etsy that make it a valuable sales tool, such as its low investment fees and competitive market. Additionally, we will delve into the emotional connection that many sellers have with Etsy and the metrics they consider when evaluating its worth. By the end of this article, you will have a clearer understanding of whether selling on Etsy is right for you.

The Complicated Relationship with Etsy

Sellers on Etsy often have a complicated relationship with the platform. They may have experienced slow or non-existent sales, leading them to question its value. However, many continue to use Etsy as a tool to make sales alongside their own websites. Despite the frustrations, Etsy still offers a way to reach potential customers and generate additional revenue.

Using Etsy as a Sales Tool

One of the main reasons sellers choose to stay on Etsy is its effectiveness as a sales tool. While it may not be their primary platform, Etsy provides an additional avenue to showcase and sell their products. By utilizing both Etsy and their website, sellers can maximize their reach and increase their chances of making sales.

Low Investment Fees

Unlike other e-commerce platforms, Etsy offers a low investment fee structure. While there is a small listing fee of 20 cents per item, this is negligible for sellers who create handmade products. Additionally, each listing remains active for four months before needing renewal. This low investment allows sellers to have a presence on Etsy without significant financial strain, making it an attractive option for those on a budget.

The Competitive Nature of Etsy

Etsy is known for its competitive nature, but it can also work in a seller's favor. For certain niches and items, Etsy remains a viable platform for generating sales. While the market may be saturated in some categories, others still offer ample opportunities for sellers to thrive. Understanding your specific niche and the demand for your products is crucial in determining whether Etsy is the right place to sell.

Etsy as the Best Fit for Your Business

When considering all the available e-commerce platforms, Etsy may still be the best fit for certain businesses. Even though Etsy has evolved beyond its handmade reputation, it still attracts a unique customer base that may align with your target audience. Sellers need to assess their own business goals and evaluate if Etsy aligns with their vision and target market.

Emotional Connection to Etsy

Despite the frustrations and controversies surrounding Etsy, many sellers feel a deep emotional connection to the platform. It is often the place where they started their business, built their brand, and achieved success. This emotional attachment makes it difficult for sellers to completely sever ties with Etsy, even if other platforms offer better opportunities.

Metrics to Consider

Ultimately, the decision to stay on Etsy boils down to metrics such as sales, revenue, and profit. Sellers must evaluate if the time and effort they invest in Etsy result in significant financial returns. By comparing these metrics against their efforts, sellers can determine if Etsy is genuinely worth it for their business.


In conclusion, selling on Etsy can be both rewarding and challenging. While the platform has its limitations, it can still serve as a valuable tool for generating sales and reaching customers. From its low investment fees to its competitive market, Etsy offers unique advantages that sellers should carefully consider. Ultimately, sellers need to assess their own business goals, audience, and metrics before deciding if Etsy is worth it for them.


Q: How does Etsy compare to other e-commerce platforms like eBay or Amazon? A: Each platform has its own strengths and weaknesses. Etsy is known for its handmade reputation and can be a better fit for certain niche products. It ultimately depends on your business and target market.

Q: Can I sell non-handmade items on Etsy? A: While Etsy has expanded its product categories, it still retains a handmade reputation. Non-handmade items may be more challenging to sell on Etsy compared to other platforms.

Q: How can I stand out in the competitive Etsy market? A: To stand out, focus on your unique selling points, product quality, and customer service. Additionally, effective marketing and branding strategies can help you attract customers on Etsy.

Browse More Content