Discover Hidden Etsy Gems for Higher Profits

Discover Hidden Etsy Gems for Higher Profits

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Blankets
    1. Fleece or Sherpa Blankets
    2. Moon Phases Blanket
    3. Hunting and Fishing Blanket
    4. Personalized Blanket
  3. Pillows
    1. ZIP Code Pillow
    2. Birth Announcement Pillow
  4. Curtains
    1. Baby Room Curtain
    2. Shower Curtain
  5. Bath Mats
    1. Get Naked Bath Mat
  6. Canvas Prints
    1. Farmhouse Wall Decor
    2. Personalized Grandkids Print
  7. Bonus Product: Prints
    1. Grandma's Garden Print
  8. Conclusion

Five Overlooked Etsy Print-on-Demand Products That Are Earning More Profit

Are you tired of selling the same old products like t-shirts and mugs on Etsy? If you want to increase your profits and stand out from the competition, I have five overlooked Etsy print-on-demand products that could be a game-changer for your business. In this article, I will share with you these hidden gems and show you where you can find them. Don't forget to think about the designs you already have and how they can be applied to these products to scale your Etsy print on-demand business.


Blankets are a versatile product that can offer higher profit margins compared to traditional items like t-shirts. Let's explore different types of blankets that you can offer in your Etsy store.

  • Fleece or Sherpa Blankets: These cozy blankets are a hit among customers. You can sell them in various designs, such as moon phases or hunting and fishing themes. With prices ranging from $62.90 to $74.37, you can make a profit of $25 to $35 per sale.
  • Personalized Blankets: Offering personalized blankets adds a personal touch for customers. By creating customized designs, you can charge higher prices starting from $71.99 and make a profit of at least $25, depending on the size of the blanket.


Pillows are another overlooked product category that can bring in good profit margins. Let's explore the possibilities of selling unique pillows on Etsy.

  • ZIP Code Pillow: Printing ZIP codes on pillows is an innovative idea that can resonate with customers. These pillows are selling for $36, and you can source them for as low as $12.23 with the premium version of Printify. This enables a profit margin of $23.77 per sale.
  • Birth Announcement Pillow: Personalized pillows for newborns are a great niche product. With a selling price of $48, you can source them for $11.43, resulting in a profit of $36.57 per sale.


Curtains may not be the first product that comes to mind when thinking about Etsy, but they can be a profitable addition to your store.

  • Baby Room Curtain: Offering curtains for baby rooms allows you to tap into a niche market. These curtains are selling for $58.50, and you can source them for $27.41, giving you a profit margin of $31.09 per sale.

Bath Mats

Bath mats can be a unique and fun product to sell on Etsy. Let's explore the potential profit margins of bath mats.

  • "Get Naked" Bath Mat: This cheeky bath mat is currently selling for $26 and is in high demand with 19 carts. With a sourcing price of $11.36, you can earn a profit of $14.64 per sale.

Canvas Prints

Canvas prints are a popular choice for wall decor on Etsy. Let's explore the profitability of offering canvas prints.

  • Farmhouse Wall Decor: Selling canvas prints with farmhouse-themed designs can attract customers looking for rustic and minimalist home decor. These prints priced at $100 can be sourced for as low as $15.78, resulting in a profit margin of $84.22 per sale.
  • Personalized Grandkids Print: Offering personalized prints with customized flower designs for each grandchild can make for a sentimental gift. These prints are priced at $53.25, and with a sourcing cost of $15.78, you can earn a profit of $37.47 per sale.

Bonus Product: Prints

I have a bonus product idea for you- prints! One specific example is a print called "Grandma's Garden." This personalized print, featuring the names of grandchildren, is currently selling for $53.25 and is in high demand with 20+ carts. With a sourcing cost of $15.78, you can earn a profit of $37.47 per sale. This product has been generating over $30,000 in monthly sales for some sellers.


Don't limit yourself to selling traditional Etsy products. By exploring overlooked print-on-demand items like blankets, pillows, curtains, bath mats, and canvas prints, you can increase your profits and stand out from the competition. Think outside the box and leverage creative designs to attract customers. With these hidden gems, your Etsy print-on-demand business has the potential to thrive.


  1. Explore overlooked Etsy print-on-demand products
  2. Blankets: Fleece or Sherpa blankets, personalized designs
  3. Pillows: ZIP code pillows, birth announcement pillows
  4. Curtains: Baby room curtains, shower curtains
  5. Bath mats: Unique and fun designs
  6. Canvas prints: Farmhouse wall decor, personalized prints
  7. Bonus product: Prints generating $30,000+ monthly sales
  8. Stand out from the competition and increase profits on Etsy


Q: Are these products saturated on Etsy?

A: While some products, like t-shirts and mugs, may be saturated on Etsy, the products mentioned in this article are often overlooked. By offering unique designs and targeting specific niches, you can tap into a market that has less competition.

Q: How can I source these products for my Etsy store?

A: You can use print-on-demand platforms like Printify to source and create these products. Printify offers a wide range of products, suppliers, and customization options to fulfill your orders.

Q: What makes these products more profitable than traditional items like t-shirts?

A: These products typically have higher price points, allowing for better profit margins. Additionally, offering niche-specific designs and personalized options can attract customers willing to spend more on unique and customized products.

Q: Are there any additional costs involved in selling these products on Etsy?

A: When selling on Etsy, you should consider listing fees, transaction fees, and shipping costs. It is important to factor in these costs when determining your pricing and profit margins.

Q: How can I market these products effectively on Etsy?

A: To effectively market these products on Etsy, optimize your product listings with keywords, high-quality images, and detailed descriptions. Utilize social media platforms to promote your products and engage with your target audience. Additionally, consider collaborating with influencers or running targeted advertising campaigns to reach a wider audience.

Browse More Content